ASOIAF Characters vs. Ser Arthur Dayne: The Ultimate Rivalry

The question of which ASOIAF character would be the best to champion in a trial by combat against Ser Arthur Dayne is one that requires deep consideration. Arthur Dayne is renowned for his exceptional skill and honor, making this a high-stakes scenario. Let's explore the options and determine who the best champion would be.

Brienne of Tarth: A Virtuous Champion

Brienne of Tarth stands as an ideal choice to represent us in this trial. Not only is she a highly skilled warrior, but she also embodies the virtues of loyalty, courage, and honor. Her combat skills, particularly with swordsmanship, and her resilience would provide a strong chance against such a formidable opponent. Additionally, her moral compass and determination would ensure that she fights with both skill and integrity. This would make her a worthy advocate in this intense battle.

Jon Snow: A Mightier Champion

After considering the sixth book of ASOIAF, I might opt for Jon Snow. If Jon managed to disarm Mance Rayder, who fights with two swords like Arthur Dayne, and managed to best Mance in combat multiple times, it suggests that his fighting skills have grown extraordinarily. Mance Rayder not only defeated Styr but also killed over a hundred wights. Additionally, Tormund Giantsbane was bested by Jon. These feats indicate that Jon's combat skills are indeed exceptional and could potentially be more than a match for Ser Arthur Dayne.

Other Contender Options

The Mountain

Although physically the strongest contender, The Mountain is too slow and lacks intelligence. This makes him a less reliable choice for a formal duel. His lack of strategic thinking and speed would likely hinder his performance.

The Red Viper

The Red Viper is another skilled option but tends to become complacent. This trait would be detrimental in a high-stakes battle, as it could compromise his focus and effectiveness in combat.

Khal Drogo

Khal Drogo is the fiercest and has the most combat experience. However, his refusal to wear armor makes him vulnerable to serious injury or even death in a formal duel against more determined and physically adept opponents.

Jaime Lannister and Barristan the Bold

Jaime Lannister and Barristan the Bold are among the best swordsmen in Westeros but lack the brute strength that some others possess. While their swordsmanship is top-notch, their physical prowess may not be sufficient against a legendary knight like Ser Arthur Dayne.

Arya Stark and Jaqen Hghar

Arya Stark, once fully trained, and Jaqen Hghar could be interesting choices but rely heavily on stealth and surprise. This would be unhelpful in a formal duel, where both opponents have a chance to see and counteract each other's moves.

Robert Baratheon: The Best Choice?

Robert Baratheon, referred to as the Demon of the Trident, is considered the best choice. He is renowned for his victories without the use of dragons, making him the only man to conquer the Seven Kingdoms. With extensive combat experience and a giant warhammer, Robert was deemed by Ned Stark to be a superior fighter to Jaime Lannister, Barristan Selmy, and even Arthur Dayne in single combat. His physical strength, combined with tactical intelligence, makes him an excellent candidate.

Choosing Based on the Show

However, if the question referred to the television show, Game of Thrones, the choice would be different. Bronn, the master of coin and Lord of Highgarden, stands out as the most logical choice. Despite the producers giving him effective immunity from serious consequences, his character's journey in the show has been remarkable. Bronn has faced numerous dangerous situations, from squaring off against Kingsguard members to battling powerful antagonists and even a dragon. His immunity to serious consequences, whether from narrative or plot armor, would make him a formidable and unconventional choice.

In conclusion, the decision on who to champion in a trial by combat against Ser Arthur Dayne is influenced by both the books and the show. While various characters have their unique strengths, the selection ultimately depends on whether we are focusing on literary prowess or narrative impact.