Alfred: The Ideal Hero or the Fatal Flaw?

At one point in comics, the most sensible age of Post-Crisis era, a fascinating concept arises: what if Alfred Pennyworth donned the iconic Batman suit?

Jim Gordon's Reflection

Jim Gordon, a seasoned detective, closes a case with Batman, leaving him alone in his musings. Captions in the narrative begin to ponder the irretrievable opportunities that life presents. At the age of 8, you lose the chance to become an Olympic gymnast. Not unless you started training rigorously and from an incredibly young age. The same goes for aspiring heroes from an early age. Gordon reflects:

At one point in my life, I could have been one of them. I could have taken on the mantle of something like Batman… But I couldn't anymore. Life got in the way, responsibilities piled up, and by then, it was too late.

As Jim ponders, he suffers a sudden heart attack, symbolizing the mental burden of past missed opportunities and regrets.

Alfred's Background

Alfred Pennyworth is a character whose background is rich with detail. A war hero from the Falklands, his early training as a medical corpsman and his innate skills as an automotive mechanic set a solid foundation for his heroism. His wit and sarcasm, often directed humorously at Bruce Wayne, are legendary. Yet, despite his impressive history, Alfred never dedicated himself fully to the path of becoming a symbol of justice like Bruce Wayne.

The Question of Heroic Potential

Could Alfred, despite his skills, become a competent superhero? The answer is nuanced:

Alfred has the potential, perhaps, to become a competent hero. However, being as excellent as Batman is highly improbable.

Becoming Batman involves not just physical training and medical knowledge, but a mental and emotional journey that requires dedicating one's entire life to the role. Despite his vast skills, Alfred never pursued such an all-encompassing path.

Without the rigorous and lifelong training required to maintain the Batman persona, Alfred would face multiple challenges. He might fall into a cycle of exhaustion, combat fatigue, or even psychological breakdown. The relentless and often brutal nature of Batman's work would fraying Alfred's nerves and take its toll rapidly.

Conclusion and Relevance

While Alfred's skills and background make him an excellent hero, the role of Batman requires a level of dedication that few, if any, can achieve. His strength lies in his support, wit, and ability to manage the more mundane aspects of Gotham's protectorate. Alfred is undoubtedly better suited to a life dedicated to support and guidance, rather than the intense and relentless duties of Donning the cape and cowl.

In summary, while Alfred's skills are vast and exceptional, the long-term success and stability achieved by dedicating one's life to such an intense hero would be damning, and potentially fatal to Alfred's mental and physical well-being.