When Will You Understand That Anime Isn’t Just a Cartoony Cartoon?

It's high time we get a little clarity on the subject of Japanese animes. Firstly, let's clarify that all anime simply refers to Japanese animation. All cartoons, on the other hand, are a type of visual art that typically involves unrealistic or semi-realistic styles of drawing and animation. Many animes fall into the category of cartoons, but there's a multitude of variation within the classifications that extend far beyond what one might categorize as a 'cartoony' cartoon.

The Diversity of Anime and Cartoons

Some Japanese animation and their stories indeed stand out in a league of their own, a unique blend of storytelling, art style, and themes that can span the gamut from the whimsical to the profound. Does this make it a cartoon? Technically, yes. However, labeling everything as a cartoon ends up doing a disservice to the cultural richness and depth of these works. It's much more nuanced than that.

Consider popular names like Doraemon, Pokemon, and the early Hello Kitty shows. These are indeed examples of semi-realistic animation, and thus fall under the category of cartoons. However, there's a vast array of anime that lean more towards realism. Titles like Steins;Gate, which deals with complex science fiction concepts, or Fairy Tail, which combines adventuring elements with fantastical world-building, are far more grounded in realism than many traditionally perceived cartoons.

Take, for instance, the traditional Japanese art forms such as Sakura Wars or Lucky Star. These are adult-oriented series that delve into complex social dynamics, relationships, and the intricacies of everyday life. Their realism and depth challenge the notion that anime is inherently juvenile or cartoonish, much like the same can be said for cartoons with their own range of complexity and maturity.

Breaking the Stereotypes

The real issue seems to lie not in the classification of these works but in the incorrect assumptions and stereotypes that surround the term 'anime.' Many people associate the word with a sort of cultural shame or embarrassment, as if it's somehow less than a so-called 'real' form of art. This ties in with the general perception in some circles that cartoons are inherently less worthy than live-action or more 'mature' forms of storytelling.

I'm speaking as a Japanese woman, having grown up in Japan and being well-versed in anime. I personally find it frustrating when such fundamental misunderstandings persist, especially when I hear my mother or others refer to anime as 'cartoons.' It’s not just a matter of semantics; it's about acknowledging the vast range and depth of storytelling and art that anime encompasses.

Why the Misunderstanding Persists

The reason behind the confusion likely lies in the historical context and development of both forms of animation. Many early Western cartoons were indeed more cartoony, with exaggerated features and fantastical elements. However, as animation evolved, both forms began to overlap in terms of the range of stories and artistic styles they could achieve. Sadly, this historical context has led to lingering stereotypes that can confound even those who engage extensively with the medium.

It's time we move beyond these outdated and harmful stereotypes. Anime and cartoons can be appreciated on their own merits, free from the expectations and biases that accompany such labels. The diversity of stories, artistic styles, and cultural insights found in anime offers a rich tapestry of human experience, just like any other form of visual art.

Conclusion

To those who continue to say "anime is just cartoons" or "anime isn't real animation," I implore you to reconsider. Whether it’s the whimsical adventures of Dragon Ball Z, the poignant stories of Dororo, or the thought-provoking narratives of Summer Wars, anime is a medium steeped in its own unique artistic traditions and cultural significance. It’s time to move past the stereotypes and embrace the full range of creativity and storytelling that anime and cartoons have to offer.