Can EMS Be Formed with Different Mangekyou Sharingan in Both Eyes?

The query revolves around the possibility of forming the Eye of Master (ECT) Sword (EMS) with different Mangekyou Sharingan abilities in both the right and left eyes. For example, would it be feasible to have Kamui in one eye and Amaterasu in the other?

Technical Feasibility and Existing Examples

Technically, it is possible to have such a configuration, but there are limitations. The Kamui ability, which requires the use of both eyes, makes it challenging to solely place it in one eye while also having Amaterasu in the other. There are two alternative considerations:

Obito’s Switch-Dimension Ability: Without the Kamui ability in one eye, a similar effect might be achieved using Obito’s ability to switch dimensions. This would allow for one eye to be occupied with Amaterasu while the other remains empty or filled with another ability. Kakashi’s Dimensional Pincushion: Alternatively, one could use Kakashi’s ability to lock people in another dimension, freeing up one eye for Amaterasu. This would allow both eyes to be used for different abilities, albeit with a slightly different mechanism.

Examples and Counterexamples in the Anime Series

Firstly, let’s consider the paired abilities. They are often seen together, such as Sasuke’s Amaterasu and Kaguro’s Kagura. Normally, Amaterasu can only be activated once it has completely burnt whatever it touches to ash. This symbiotic relationship makes these abilities effectively paired and complementary.

Secondly, Itachi’s pair of Mangekyou Sharingan—Amaterasu and Tsukiyomi—demonstrates a mismatch in abilities. Tsukiyomi, a powerful genjutsu, does not complement Amaterasu’s destructive nature. It proves that it is possible to have mismatched abilities, just not in a straightforward and symbiotic manner.

These examples suggest that while the EMS can exist with mismatched abilities, having different abilities in each eye requires some form of workaround, such as dimension-hopping techniques.

Possible Interpretations of the Question

The question is open to interpretation. If it is asking whether having Kamui in one eye and Amaterasu in the other is possible, the answer is yes, considering the alternative methods mentioned earlier. However, if it is asking whether the EMS can inherently be formed with those specific abilities in each eye without any workarounds, then it is more complex and may not be feasible.

Conclusion

The formation of EMS with different Mangekyou Sharingan abilities in each eye is theoretically possible but requires specific conditions and workarounds. The existing examples in the series provide guidance, showing that the EMS can indeed be formed with mismatched but differently paired abilities. If you wish to verify my interpretation or have any further questions, feel free to ask.