Colt 45 and Astra 600: Cost, Performance, and Availability

When considering a 1911 pistol in .45 ACP, the choice between a Colt brand and a Tisas brand can significantly impact both price and performance. Here, we explore the costs, performance, and availability of these firearms.

Cost of a Colt M1911

For those who wish to purchase a genuine Colt M1911 in .45 ACP, the price range starts around $750. Higher-end models can command even more, reflecting the brand's prestige and quality. Should you opt for a firearm with similar specifications but a lesser-known brand, you can find a Tisas 1911A1 for around $300. These Turkish-made pistols offer a well-crafted, although not officially branded, option that may serve as a suitable firearm to gauge your interest in a more expensive colt.

Comparison with Other Brands

While a Colt M1911 is a high-end choice, it's important to compare it with other firearms available on the market. For instance, the Astra 600, although no longer in production since 1945, is a viable alternative if you prefer a lighter and more maneuverable weapon. This older model, especially the Astra 400, which was a predecessor to the 600, offered a different shooting experience with its .38 caliber rounds.

Cost and Availability

Decades ago, I purchased a new automatic 1911-style Colt 45 for around $1000 in California, but prices vary depending on the state's gun laws and restrictions. As of the present, due to stricter regulations in California and other anti-gun states, the price for a new Colt 45 is significantly higher, ranging from $1800 in California to approximately $1400 in other states.

In contrast, a used Astra 600 automatic can be found for around $200 to $300, making it a more budget-friendly choice. The Astra 600 not only costs less but also weighs less, offering a more comfortable and practical option for daily use. Additionally, the Astra 600 fires a 9mm round, making it a versatile choice for those who prefer different ammunition options.

Performance and Feel

Performance-wise, the Astra 600 offers a more comfortable shooting experience compared to a .45 ACP. Its lighter weight and better ergonomics make it easier to handle, especially for those used to shotguns like I was in the military. Although I've not been to a range in about 7 years, my experience suggests that the Astra 600 provides a more natural and enjoyable shooting experience, even for those who previously qualified as an expert with a .45 ACP.

Conclusion

In summary, the choice between a Colt 45 and an Astra 600 depends on various factors, including price, performance, and personal preferences. For those seeking a reliable, high-quality firearm recognized for its longevity, a Colt M1911 is a great option. However, if budget and comfort are priorities, the Astra 600 presents a compelling alternative.

For a more detailed comparison, explore the images from Colt 45 automatic and Astra 600 automatic on Google Images.