Is It Possible for Edward Elric to Use Alkahestry After Sacrificing His Gate of Truth?

According to the plot of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Edward Elric, the titular character, sacrifices his ability to use alchemy, including his connection to the Gate of Truth, to bring his brother Alphonse back to life. This brings up a question: could he still learn Alkahestry, a different form of alchemy practiced in the East, without having access to his Gate of Truth?

Traditional Alchemy and the Gate of Truth

Traditional alchemy, as practiced by Ed and his brother, requires a deep connection to the Gate of Truth, a powerful ritual that is crucial for their alchemical abilities. After sacrificing his Gate of Truth, Ed's ability to perform alchemy is effectively nullified. The Gate of Truth is a symbol of the True North and a gateway to the World of Truth, where alchemists can access profound alchemical powers.

The Possibility of Learning Alkahestry

Although the series does not explicitly state whether Ed can learn Alkahestry, it is worth noting that Alkahestry operates on principles distinct from traditional alchemy. It does not rely on the Gate of Truth. Therefore, it might be possible for Ed to study and learn Alkahestry if he were to travel to the East and train under a master practitioner.

Alkahestry is a unique form of magic that is deeply rooted in Eastern traditions, involving the use of chemical substances and the manipulation of natural elements. Unlike the rigid and formulaic nature of state alchemy, Alkahestry is more fluid and adaptable, allowing for a wider range of possibilities and less stringent limitations.

The Complexity of the Alchemy Law

Alchemy, as governed by the Law of Equivalent Exchange, requires that an equal exchange of value is made for any transformation. In the case of Ed, the cost of his brother’s life was immense, and it is unlikely that he would be willing to make another equivalent sacrifice to regain his alchemy. The law dictates that the sacrifice must be of equal value, and such a high price would make it difficult for Ed to find another willing alchemist to trade.

Conclusion

While Ed's connection to traditional alchemy is severed, the potential for him to learn Alkahestry exists but would require significant effort and training, which lies beyond the scope of the series. Capturing the essence of Alkahestry would demand not only the acquisition of knowledge but also the cultural and historical context of its practices.

Final Thoughts

The ending of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood concluded the series on a satisfying note for many fans, leaving it open to the question of whether the story could continue. While some writers might explore alternative continuations, it remains unlikely that Ed would regain his alchemical abilities, given the strictures of the Law of Equivalent Exchange and the high cost of his initial sacrifice.