Do Vulcans Value Humanoids Over Other Beings?

When considering the value Vulcans place on humanoids, it's important to examine the portrayal of these characters in Star Trek, particularly in the series Enterprise.

The Enterprise Take on Vulcans

Watching Enterprise was an intriguing experience, especially from a The Original Series perspective. The portrayal of Vulcans in Enterprise was quite different and, for some, it could be seen as a step backward in character development. Characters like T'Pol introduced a new level of complexity, but also controversy. T'Pol, with her strict uniform, large books, and a cold, secretive personality, was an interesting concept but fell short in terms of chemistry and character interactions.

Character Critique: T'Pol

T'Pol's character felt designed more for a storytelling device than a fully fleshed-out individual. Her portrayal was harsh, leaning towards a superiority complex. It's easy to see why some might find her off-putting, given her ethereal yet disapproving nature. For example, she presented a very sexualized yet unwelcoming approach to Trip, highlighting a potential disconnect in her interactions with the crew.

Her inability to understand why Captain Archer cherished his beagle Porthos was another point of contention. Captain Archer's bond with a pet was a tender moment, a pivotal reminder of emotional connections often lost in the rigid societal structures of Vulcans. The contrast between the two portrayals of Vulcan and human relationships in the series was stark and perhaps influenced the show's reception negatively.

Vulcan’s Relationship with Animals

It's worth noting that Vulcans, both in Enterprise and as portrayed in The Original Series, have a different relationship with animals compared to humans. This difference highlights a key aspect of Vulcans' way of life. While Sehlaits could certainly be domesticated, they fall short of the intimate companionship that humans often form with cats, dogs, and other pets.

One might argue that Vulcans value humanoids more because of the inherent connection to logical beings. In their society, the emotional and intuitive aspects of relationships with animals are less valued, emphasizing instead the logical and rational interactions with other beings, particularly humanoids.

Conclusion: The Value of Humanoids

In conclusion, the portrayal of Vulcans in Enterprise and The Original Series illustrates the complexity of their relationship with humanoids versus other beings. While the Enterprise version introduced a new layer of character development, the underlying theme of valuing logical beings over emotional ones remains consistent. Understanding this perspective can provide valuable insight into the intricacies of Vulcan society and how it differs from the more emotional representation in the older series.

Despite the characters and storytelling challenges, both shows offer a unique glimpse into the world of Vulcan and their relationship with the wider universe. Whether you're a fan of The Original Series or Enterprise, these portrayals offer a rich tapestry of emotional and intellectual depth, making them worth exploring for fans of Star Trek.