Can We Expect Yamato to Become a Nakama of the Straw Hats in One Piece?

As of my last update in August 2023, Yamato has been a focal point of discussion among One Piece fans regarding her potential to join the Straw Hat Pirates. This article delves into the factors that influence this consideration, providing insights based on the current storyline and the narrative dynamics at play.

Character Development

Throughout the Wano arc, Yamato has shown significant character growth and a strong determination to pursue freedom in line with the Straw Hats' ideals. Her journey and her future aspirations align with the crew's values, making her a fitting candidate for joining them. Fans are hopeful for her inclusion, as her presence could greatly enhance the crew's dynamic and their adventures.

Narrative Role

Yamato's role in the Wano arc has been pivotal, particularly in the fight against Kaido. Her background and powers could significantly add depth to the Straw Hats' dynamic and enhance their adventures. The potential for her to bring unique strengths and perspectives to the crew is evident, making her a compelling and promising candidate for becoming a Nakama.

Current Status

As of the latest chapters, Yamato has not officially joined the crew. There are hints and foreshadowing that suggest she might, but as with many characters in the One Piece universe, Oda often takes his time with character arcs and introductions. The question remains: will Yamato become a official member of the Straw Hats, or will her story conclude with her separate yet influential journey?

Arguments Against Yamato Becoming a Part of the Crew

While Yamato's strong character development and narrative potential are compelling, there are several reasons why she may not join the Straw Hats. One of the major issues is the presence of Oden's journal in her possession. The contents of this journal are unknown, but it is possible that it contains information related to the last island, "Laugh Tale," "One Piece," or the "Void Century." If this is the case, she should not be a part of the crew to maintain plot twists and surprises.

Additionally, there is no specific purpose for her to join the crew. The Straw Hats are already a well-rounded group, each member fulfilling distinct roles. They are sailing smoothly, with numerous adventures and moments of fun that add to their journey. Incorporating Yamato into the crew could potentially disrupt this balance, given her unique abilities and the current dynamics within the crew.

A third theory posits that after the end of the Battle in Wano, the Land of Wano will finally open up, and Yamato will become a significant figure there. According to this theory, every citizen of Wano will be aware of the outside world. Momonosuke will become the Shogun, and Yamato will lead the Samurai force, known for her "Guardian Deity of Wano." She would then serve as an ally to the Straw Hats rather than a member of the crew.

Ultimately, whether Yamato becomes a Nakama depends on Oda's narrative choices moving forward. Fans remain hopeful, and her potential inclusion would certainly excite many. However, her unique role in Wano and the plot twists associated with Oden's journal suggest that her journey may take her elsewhere, serving the Land of Wano and the Samurai force in her own distinct capacity.