How Should Carrie Fisher’s Footage Be Used in The Rise of Skywalker? Controversial Debate

Since Carrie Fisher’s passing, a significant debate has emerged around the use of her footage in The Rise of Skywalker. The question remains: Should we afford her the dignity of peace or give fans one last chance to see their beloved character?

Carrie Fisher’s Involvement and Her Opinion

It's worth noting that Fisher herself likely wouldn't mind this use of her footage. She had a strong sense of humor and a deep personal connection to Star Wars, both loving and hating it at various times. She even appeared to enjoy reenacting her iconic role as Princess Leia, as evidenced by her posthumous return to the role in Return of the Jedi. Therefore, it stands to reason that she would be comfortable with The Rise of Skywalker using her footage.

Institutional Stance and Actor Rights

Lucasfilm has taken a responsible stance by using footage that was previously filmed and not recreating it through CGI as they did in Rogue One. This approach ensures that the footage is authentic and gives fans an opportunity to say goodbye to a character they hold dear. Additionally, the decision to use this footage has been done with the consent of the surviving members of the Fisher family, further legitimizing its use.

Historical Context and Conflicting Examples

However, it's important to consider the historical context. The idea of actors "resting in peace" has been increasingly challenged with each passing year. Fred Astaire, for example, still allows his dancing in films, even years after his death. In the realm of Star Wars, it's even more vividly highlighted with the controversial inclusion of the late Peter Cushing in Rogue One, which was released long after his death.

Pros and Cons of Using Fisher’s Footage

Supporters of using Fisher’s footage argue that it allows fans to have closure and preserves her legacy. They argue that since she appeared in The Last Jedi, her presence is merely extending a storyline she was part of. Critics, on the other hand, argue that such use diminishes the idea of "rest in peace" and leaves a bittersweet feeling for the audience.

Producer’s Responsibility

Producers face a delicate balance in these situations. They are responsible for honoring the performers and their contributions, while also respecting the wishes of the remaining family. The Rise of Skywalker seems to have handled the situation responsibly by using pre-existing footage and with the consent of the Fisher family. They also avoided recreating her, which might have been seen as disrespectful or exploitative.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the decision to use Carrie Fisher's footage in The Rise of Skywalker is a nuanced one with valid arguments on both sides. However, given the circumstances and the consent of the Fisher family, it appears to be a responsible and respectful approach.