Is Steve Rogers at Peggy’s Funeral? A Detailed Analysis

The question of whether Steve Rogers is present at Peggy Carter's funeral has sparked intense debate among fans of the Captain America: Civil War movie and the broader universe of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Let's dive deep into the evidence and theories surrounding this intriguing topic.

Indication of Steve's Presence

Captain America: Civil War Scenes

One of the most compelling pieces of evidence comes from the shot of Peggy Carter's funeral in Captain America: Civil War. In the scene, Steve Rogers is seen as the front carrier of the coffin, positioned to the right of the frame. This detail has led many fans to believe that the older, grey-haired man at the back of the coffin is indeed the older Steve Rogers. This theory is further supported by the sequence of events in the movies, which suggest that Steve Rogers had returned to the past and spent more time with Peggy Carter before his final departure.

According to the timeline, Steve Rogers, having returned the Aether stones, lived a civilian life with Peggy between 1947 and 1953. It is hypothesized that he might have adopted an alias, possibly taking Peggy's last name Carter, to avoid public attention. In such a scenario, Steve would have remained unaware of Peggy's death and would not have missed her funeral.

Theoretical Absence of Steve

Another perspective considers the possibility that Steve Rogers is not present at Peggy Carter's funeral. This theory suggests that Peggy is married, and the man she is with at the funeral is her husband. It is possible that he is not willing to be recognized, which may explain why Fury does not immediately inform Captain Marvel of Steve's information. Another possible explanation is that Fury is aware of the situation but chooses to keep it confidential until the Avengers are activated.

Speculations on Steve’s Actions

Some fans argue that Steve's absence at Peggy Carter's funeral may be related to the expiry of Peggy's life. If Steve was with Peggy for a shorter period, her death may have been inevitable. However, Steve's continued possession of Peggy's wedding ring at the end of Avengers: Endgame hints that he was more deeply involved in her life than other widowers, suggesting a lingering emotional connection.

Another interesting theory suggests that Steve might have used time manipulation to stay with Peggy, potentially delaying Peggy's death. This would justify his absence at her funeral, as he never truly aged during their time together.

Other Fan Theories and Evidence

Some fans have pointed to a specific moment in the movie where Tony Stark mentions something that could be interpreted as a reference to Steve’s presence in Peggy’s life. However, this bit of evidence is highly debated and open to alternative interpretations.

The same scene also features a shot of an older man, possibly Steve Rogers, carrying a bag, which some fans believe could be further evidence of his presence at the funeral.

Further support comes from a scene in Captain America: Civil War where Natasha Romanoff shows concern for Steve after his emotional breakdown following Peggy Carter's funeral. This could be interpreted as a compassionate gesture from Natasha, who might have known about Steve's connection to Peggy.

Conclusion

The question of whether Steve Rogers attended Peggy Carter's funeral remains a part of the rich tapestry of fan theories in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Each theory provides a unique interpretation of the complex relationship between Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter, adding depth to the narrative and ongoing debates among fans.

Keep Exploring the MCU

If you are a fan of the MCU and are curious about other complex plot elements, consider exploring other theories and fan discussions. The deeper you dive, the more fascinating the web of interconnected stories becomes.