Why Do People Believe Jiraiya Could Defeat Pain?

Many individuals assume that Jiraiya, a respected and formidable ninja, could defeat Pain. This belief often stems from general knowledge about the characters and their strengths. However, the truth is more complex and nuanced.

Jiraiya's Potential Against Pain

Jiraiya, a legendary S-rank ninja and grandpa figure to Naruto, is certainly a masterful strategist and ninja. His prowess is evident in his countless battles and victories. Yet, when it comes to Pain, a towering figure known for his nine dying wills and multiple bodies, the scales tip differently. Pain's ability to control multiple bodies and his knowledge of the battlefield make him a formidable opponent for even the most skilled ninja.

Why Jiraiya Wouldn't Triumph

1. **Pain's Multiple Bodies**: Pain's multiple bodies could overwhelm Jiraiya. Even if Jiraiya were at the pinnacle of his power, attempting to defeat all of these bodies simultaneously could be insurmountable. Each body is a distinct entity, and each must be neutralized for the threat to disappear.

The Power of Multiple Bodies

2. **Pain's Genjutsu**: Pain possesses a powerful genjutsu that could paralyze Jiraiya. This is evident in Pain's partial use of the genjutsu during their first encounter. The genjutsu is based on sound, with anyone who hears the complete melody becoming paralyzed. Jiraiya was aware of this tactic and deliberately decided not to use it, recognizing the threat it posed. If Jiraiya had been fully aware of the existence of more bodies, he might have been able to defeat them, but without that knowledge, his defeat is more likely.

Genjutsu's Role in the Battle

In chapter 371, Jiraiya used his sound-based genjutsu on Pain's six bodies. He believed that none of them would be able to move. However, this tactic backfired when Pain's main body remained unparalyzed. Pain's ability to control and use different bodies effectively mitigated this advantage. The result was that Jiraiya killed only three of Pain's bodies before calling off the technique. If Jiraiya had known about the additional bodies, he may have been more successful in his initial attempt to subdue them.

Pein's Statements and Battle Logics

3. **Pein's Prediction and Jiraiya's Secret**: In chapter 383, the official translation credited to Pein states that if he had not kept his secrets, he might not have beaten Jiraiya. However, the Japanese translation suggests that if Jiraiya had known more, he may not have won. This interpretation is significant, as it indicates that Jiraiya's victory was not guaranteed. It also reflects the uncertainty and complexity of their battle.

Official Translations and Meaning

The subtle difference in translation highlights that Jiraiya was facing an opponent who had hidden knowledge and strategies. This uncertainty means that Jiraiya had to fight without full information, a factor that significantly impacted the outcome of their battle.

Conclusion: Jiraiya's Challenges Against Pain

In summary, the belief that Jiraiya could defeat Pain is fueled by a combination of Jiraiya's legendary status and the general understanding of the characters. However, the nuanced realities of their battle, including multiple bodies and a powerful genjutsu, cast doubt on this assumption. Jiraiya's defeat is more likely when considering the full scope of Pain's abilities and the hidden information that could have given him an advantage.

Therefore, while Jiraiya is undoubtedly a skilled and dangerous opponent, Pain's consistent victories and tactics make his defeat highly unlikely. The outcome of any battle, especially against an opponent as formidable as Pain, is more complex than a simple victory or defeat.

Keywords: Jiraiya, Pain, Naruto, Samping, Genjutsu