Reactions to the Removal of Core Characters in the MCU: Are You Angry or Happy?

In the recent Avengets film, the removal of three core characters—Captain America, Iron Man, and Black Widow—has sparked a range of emotions among fans. Some are angry, while others are happy, with varying degrees of satisfaction and disappointment. Let's explore these common reactions in more detail.

The Death of Iron Man

Positive Aspect: Many viewers were happy and satisfied when Iron Man died, as it provided a more emotionally impactful and just ending. Iron Man's role as a savior and hero was well-recognized, and his sacrifice fulfilled the narrative arc of a hero who becomes a martyr for a greater good. Negative Aspects: The way his death was handled left many fans feeling manipulated. The use of Iron Man as the narrator and his portrayal as surviving the battle created a sense of false hope, followed by a sudden and unexpected death. This could have been avoided if the filmmakers had been more transparent about the outcome early on. Unsatisfactory Healing Scene: For some, the scene where Thor could have potentially healed Iron Man with his godly powers was a missed opportunity. The audience's expectations were set, and the potential for a transformational healing moment was squandered. Instead, the scene left viewers feeling frustrated and let down.

The Final Moments with Captain America

The Lift of Mjolnir: Captain America finally lifting Mjolnir was a climactic moment that brought closure to his character's journey. It showcased a significant transformation and empowered him to embrace a new role. However, the use of lightning, a power traditionally associated with Thor, was a significant departure from the established mythology and left some fans questioning the consistency of the world they had come to know.

Forceful Removal: Some felt that the deaths were forced and seemed too convenient. This raised questions about the true intentions behind the removals, rather than being organic plot developments. There were concerns that the motivations behind these characters' exits were more aligned with the needs of the narrative rather than the characters' arcs.

The Ruin of Thor's Character

The Fat Thor: Perhaps the most controversial change was the reimagining of Thor as a "fat" character. This decision was met with widespread criticism, as it undermined the character's power and identity. The implication that Thor had lost his strength and authority was a significant departure from the original lore.

No Gauntlet: One of the key criticisms was that Thor was not given the ability to use the Titan's Gauntlet, which would have allowed him to be the most powerful character in the film. This was seen as a missed opportunity to provide a more satisfying resolution to Thanos's threat. The Battle Montage and 'Girl Power' Sequence: The inclusion of a 'girl power' montage during a key battle moment was seen as an unnecessary distraction. While the intention was to highlight the capabilities of the female heroes, it often felt out of place and disrupted the flow of the action. The battle scenes were complex and had multiple storylines, making the timing and inclusion of such a sequence awkward.

Conclusion

The removal of these characters, as well as the reimagining of Thor, triggered a range of emotions among fans. While the movie was thrilling due to the familiar characters and the weight of their final portrayals, there were numerous aspects that disappointed audiences. This debate is a testament to the deep connection and loyalty that fans have for the characters and the worlds they inhabit.

As the MCU continues to evolve, these discussions and reactions will shape the narrative and help define future storylines and character arcs. The experience of fans and their expectations are integral to the success and understanding of these complex characters.