Reflections on ‘Batman v Superman’ from Dedicated Superman Fans

Dedicated superman comics fans often hold the Man of Steel with a sense of reverence and adoration. However, when it comes to Batman v Superman, opinions tend to split along diverse lines. While some critics and moviegoers took offense to the film's portrayal of their beloved hero, others found it intriguing and innovative. Here, we delve into the thoughts and feelings of devoted Superman fans about this divisive cinematic endeavor.

Initial Haters

For many die-hard superman comics fans, the movie felt like an affront to everything they hold dear about Superman. Characters like Jimmy Olsen, a quintessential part of the Superman lore, were absent from the film. Lex Luthor's off-screen presence felt overbearing, and Lois Lane was depicted as less than her usual dynamic self. The film did not uphold Superman's traditional traits, leaving fans feeling disappointed and even angry. Writer Zack Snyder, known for his distinctive style, arguably took a different approach to the character, portraying Superman in a less idealized, more grounded manner.

Redefining Superman

While some fans bemoan the changes, others see Snyder's vision as a necessary evolution. Many Superman fans recognize that the character is not meant to be a Big Blue Boy Scout who never lets anyone die or kill. Instead, they believe that giving Superman more flaws and making him relatable can add depth to the character. The film delves into the concept of heroism and what it means to be a hero, even in the face of impossible odds. This approach challenges the audience and offers a more mature and complex take on the iconic hero.

Personal Reflections

Having seen Batman v Superman several times now, I can certainly categorize myself among those who see the film as an interesting take on an established superhero narrative. The movie tackles a wide range of themes, including character arcs, realism, and the complexities of heroism. It's not intended to be a feel-good romp or a simple adventure story but rather a film that seeks to inject as much realism as possible to elevate it beyond mere wish-fulfillment. The portrayal of Superman as flawed and capable of action, even in difficult situations, is both daring and thought-provoking.

The Unconventional Approach

The film's unconventional approach to filmmaking has led to mixed reviews. While some viewers may struggle with the lack of traditional, feel-good superhero dynamics, others find it refreshing and innovative. Unlike many modern blockbusters, Batman v Superman doesn't seek to please the lowest common denominator. Instead, Zack Snyder took the path of something more mature and oriented towards adult audiences, drawing from various sources such as graphic novels and animations. This choice was evident in its storytelling and visual style, reflecting the maturity and complexity often associated with these alternative mediums.

Lincoln: A Maturity Upgrade in Film

Moreover, the film serves as a reminder of the effort to elevate superhero storytelling. Like Lincoln, another film by the same director, the movie aims to be more than just eye candy or nostalgia. Snyder's focus was on the narrative and filmmaking techniques, rather than mindless spectacle or simple fan service. This deliberate choice to ground the action in realistic outcomes and mature themes marked a significant departure from the typical superhero movie formula that many fans and critics alike have come to expect.

Future of DC Films

The two films, Man of Steel and Batman v Superman, can be seen as the first steps in a new, more complex universe for DC films. These movies serve as the foundation for a larger, interconnected narrative that promises to continue exploring the characters and their stories in greater depth. Fans can hope that future installments will build upon this foundation, further exploring the nuances of the characters and narratives.

Conclusion

Overall, my experience with Batman v Superman has been one of enjoyment and fascination. The film's unorthodox approach to superhero storytelling, its mature themes, and its complex characterization are what set it apart from the crowd. As a true fan of Superman's legacy, I appreciate the efforts to provide a more nuanced and relatable take on the character, making Batman v Superman an exciting and thought-provoking addition to the DC cinematic universe.