Reflections on Bane: The Dark Knight Rises

Have you ever loved and hated a character at the same time? Below, I explore my thoughts on Bane from The Dark Knight Rises. Let's start with the sound of his voice which is also a point of contention—a voice that on the surface seems silly and easy to mock. However, there's a reason behind it.

The Voice and Mirror Image of Batman

Tom Hardy's voice for Bane does sound odd and it is easy to make fun of, but it served a purpose. The voice mirrors Batman's in the film series, capturing that brutal and rage-filled tone. Batman sounds perpetually on the ragged edge, often teetering on the brink of breaking. In contrast, Bane is described as calm and sophisticated, always in control. Despite being beaten to a pulp, Bane maintains his composure, symbolizing his superior control and mental fortitude.

Deconstructing Bane's Gotham Campaign

One of the strengths of Bane in the film is his destructive campaign in Gotham. He dismantles the city with a strategic and relentless approach. However, a significant turning point comes in the third act when it is revealed that Bane is actually working for Miranda/Talia. This revelation felt disheartening and undermined the buildup of Bane's character. Similar feelings were expressed in the comics and cartoons where Bane often served as a primary antagonist, then became a sidekick, which I found inconsistent with his established legacy.

The Film's Place in the Trilogy

The Dark Knight Rises is often cited as the weakest entry in the Batman film trilogy. Nonetheless, I adored Tom Hardy's performance as Bane. My only criticism is that his character was reduced to a sidekick at the film's conclusion and was killed off unexpectedly, which felt anticlimactic.

The Revitalization of Bane

Tom Hardy's portrayal of Bane is refreshing and powerful. His appearance brings a new life to the character, embodying pure rage and bravado. Hardy's dialogue is a blend of dark, sinister, and thought-provoking wit, often bordering on trolling as he challenges his opponents. There's a depth to Bane that I found lacking in previous depictions, where he was typically portrayed as just a super-strong henchman.

Final Thoughts

The transformation of Bane from a primary antagonist to a sidekick is a critical flaw in the film's narrative. It detracts from his character's depth and the satisfaction in his ultimate victory. However, Tom Hardy's performance, especially, elevates Bane in the public's perception. The question remains, is this film's Bane truly reflective of the character's true essence in the comics and cartoons?

In summary, while there are valid criticisms, the performance of Tom Hardy as Bane in The Dark Knight Rises is a standout element that deserves recognition. What are your thoughts on Bane's portrayal in this film? Is there a definitive version of Bane that you prefer?