Reflections on Sword Art Online Post-Aincrad and Alfheim Arcs

Sword Art Online remains a popular and engaging series for many fans. However, after the Aincrad and Alfheim arcs, the series' focus and development take an interesting turn. In this article, I will discuss my thoughts on the inclusion of harem elements and their impact on the show, specifically on the relationship dynamics between Kirito and Asuna.

Personal Opinion: Harem Elements and Romance

Let's be clear from the outset: Sword Art Online is still an enjoyable and engaging series. The romance elements in the show are generally well-written and can be compelling. However, the series takes several narrative turns that make the inclusion of harem elements somewhat questionable. These moments are highly subjective and based on my personal experience and opinion, so feel free to disagree with my perspective.

Focus on Romance vs. Harem Elements

The show would be most appealing if it focused solely on the romantic relationship between Kirito and Asuna. However, the harem elements significantly detract from this potential. Kirito has multiple new love interests introduced in each subsequent arc, often immediately faced with resistance from Asuna, the primary female protagonist. In the Phantom Bullet arc, Kirito meets Sinon, who becomes a potential love interest. Similarly, in the Alicization arc, Alice Ronie, Sortiliena, and again Sinon are introduced. Even more, Asuna's sister and cousin have been part of Kirito's harem since the Fairy Dance arc in Alfheim. Asuna is portrayed as fully aware of these relationships and seemingly accepting of them, which is a significant departure from a character traditionally portrayed as Kirito's primary partner.

Lack of Romantic Moments and Harem Dynamics

After the Fairy Dance arc, the series frequently shifts between romantic moments with Asuna and scenes where Kirito is simultaneously attracted to multiple harem members. This flip-flopping can weaken the romantic narrative. For instance, in the Calibur arc, Sinon asks Kirito to think of her when he uses Excalibur, while Asuna, Lisbeth, and Silica stand by in disappointment. This portrayal suggests that Asuna's relationship with Kirito is more of a platonic bond or a harem member rather than a significant romantic one. As a viewer, this makes it difficult to root for the romantic development of Kirito and Asuna.

The Alicization Arc and Kirito's Power Dynamics

While I commend the Alicization arc for giving Kirito a more challenging and realistic portrayal, it seems that the series' narrative balance might have shifted too far from a focused romantic storyline. Kirito's power dynamics were often exaggerated, which detracts from the genuine development of his character and his relationship with Asuna. For example, in a scene where Kirito faces a high-powered Integrity Knight, he seemingly maintains his strength despite his damaged soul. Such moments diminish the viewer's ability to trust in Kirito's character development.

Conclusion: An Enjoyable Show with Flaws

Ultimately, Sword Art Online isn't a terrible show, and the Alicization arc is generally excellent. However, it falls short in certain areas, particularly in the harem elements and the insistence on portraying Kirito as overwhelmingly powerful. While it remains an enjoyable watch, it doesn't hold the top spot in my rankings, with series like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood and Fate/Stay Night taking precedence for me. Other high-quality shows like Hellsing Ultimate also compete for attention in my top ten.

In summary, Sword Art Online is a good series, albeit with notable flaws. These flaws become more evident once you start looking for them. Enjoy the show, but don't expect it to be a perfect romance series, as the harem elements often overshadow the romantic elements between Kirito and Asuna.