Reviving Jiraiya: Would It Be Kashin or Jiraiya Through Edo Tensei?
Reviving Jiraiya: Would It Be Kashin or Jiraiya Through Edo Tensei?
In the intricate world of Naruto lore, the concept of Edo Tensei (From the World of the Living), a technique that permits the revival of deceased individuals, holds a significant place. This technique raises several intriguing questions, one of which is:
Considering Kashin Koji, a clone of Jiraiya, if Kabuto were to use his blood for Edo Tensei purposes, would Jiraiya or Kashin be revived?
Understanding the Context
Kashin Koji, possessing Jiraiya's abilities and some of his memories, is acknowledged as a distinct entity. However, the core question revolves around whether his blood would enable the revival of Jiraiya or Kashin Koji himself.
Cloning and Revival Mechanics
Traditional norms within the Naruto series suggest that only one soul can be revived through Edo Tensei. This means that if you use Kashin Koji's blood, the revived entity would almost certainly be Jiraiya himself, given his direct connection as the original soul.
Debating the Possibilities
Some argue that the remains used for reviving would match the individual brought back, but this remains up for debate. For example, the Gold-Silver Brothers required two bodies to bring back a single soul, further supporting the theory that one soul corresponds to one body.
Unique Identity of Kashin Koji
Kashin Koji, despite sharing DNA with Jiraiya, is a separate individual with his own soul and distinct personality. Using Jiraiya's remains would therefore bring back Jiraiya's soul. Conversely, using Kashin Koji's remains would bring back his soul, leading to the revival of Kashin Koji.
Uncertainty and Authorial Influence
The exact outcome relies heavily on the continuity and authorial decisions within the Naruto series. Certain variables, such as the modifications made by Amado, factor into the final decision:
If Kashin Koji was the direct clone of Jiraiya without any modifications, the revival would likely follow the DNA match. However, Amado's modifications, which he has applied to all members of Kara, could differentiate Kashin Koji as a unique entity compared to Jiraiya. Even with perfect DNA equality, there is a possibility that the soul chosen from the Pure Land would be random, allowing for the reviving of both and then discarding the unwanted one.Given the complexity introduced by these factors, the scenario remains speculative. Unless the author clarifies this, we might never definitively know the correct outcome.
Conclusion
The revival process through Edo Tensei remains an enigmatic concept within the Narutocanon. Based on current understanding and accepted lore, using Jiraiya's remains would most likely bring back Jiraiya, while using Kashin Koji's remains would activate the revival of Kashin Koji himself. The exact manifestation depends on various factors, including DNA modifications and the random selection of souls from the Pure Land.