The Admission of Self-Trained Force Users to the Jedi Order: An Analysis

If an adult self-trained powerful force user applied to the Jedi Order would they be accepted? The answer, in most cases, is a resounding no, but it involves more than just the age of the applicant. The strict vetting process and the criteria required for entry are critical factors.

Strict Entry Criteria and Vetting Process

The Jedi Order is known for its strict entry criteria and rigorous training process. Any adult who wishes to join the Order, let alone become a full member, must undergo extensive evaluation and training. The primary concern for the Jedi is the potential for falling to the Dark Side, a highly dangerous and unpredictable outcome.

Being self-trained is a significant hurdle. The self-trained individual likely believes they have mastered the Jedi way and are resistant to the Dark Side. However, this confidence is often misplaced. The Jedi Order is not merely about wielding the Force or using a lightsaber. It is a deep-seated understanding of Jedi theology, philosophy, history, culture, and practices, which cannot be acquired through self-study alone.

The Problem with Self-Trained Applicants

The issue with self-trained force users is not their inherent ability to use the Force or wield a lightsaber. Instead, it is their arrogance and belief that they no longer need to learn. This mindset is a major red flag for the Jedi Order. Being a Jedi Knight involves a complete transformation and relearning of the Force. The self-trained user:

Believes they have figured it all out: They may think they possess all the necessary knowledge and skills without the need for further training. Arsenal of arrogance: Their arrogance may prevent them from understanding the potential flaws in their current knowledge and skills. Terrible student: They are likely unwilling to unlearn their current knowledge and start from the beginning.

The self-trained applicant would be seen as having a significant knowledge gap and being a potential liability for the Order. They would be vetted and studied for a long time to gauge their true abilities and intentions. Even if they prove to be skilled, their lack of proper training means they would not be trusted as a full Jedi Knight.

The Example of Darth Motti and the Jedi Philosophy

In A New Hope, Imperial Admiral Motti's statement to Darth Vader highlights the Jedi philosophy and its fundamental principles. Motti says, "Your sad devotion to that ancient religion has not helped you conjure up the stolen data tapes or given you clairvoyance enough to find the Rebels hidden fort."

Motti's words may be a misinterpretation of the Jedi Order, conflating it with the Sith. However, he makes a valid point: being a follower of the Jedi religion or philosophy requires more than just a fleeting understanding of the Force. It involves a deep immersion in the Order's teachings, practices, and cultural heritage.

Without a thorough understanding and immersion in Jedi theology, philosophy, history, and culture, a self-trained force user would merely be a figure with some Force powers and a lightsaber. This is not what being a Jedi Knight is about. The Order seeks individuals who are dedicated to the ways of the Force and willing to undergo the transformative training required to become a true Jedi Knight.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while an adult self-trained force user may possess impressive abilities, their lack of formal training and willingness to unlearn and relearn mean they are unlikely to be accepted into the Jedi Order as a full member. Vetting and rigorous training are essential for ensuring the Order's purity and strength, and a self-trained applicant would be seen as a significant risk.