The Debate Over Pokémon Ash Should Have Kept: A Deep Dive

In the popular Pokémon anime, fans often hash out debates about which Pokémon Ash Ketchum should have never released. This article explores the top contenders, including Charizard, Butterfree, Squirtle, and Greninja, and delves into why these Pokémon made such a significant impact on Ash's journey.

The Charizard Controversy

Many fans believe that Ash should have never released Charizard, one of his most iconic Pokémon. Charizard was a crucial part of Ash's team, showcasing a strong bond and impressive battles, particularly during the Johto and Battle Frontier arcs. While Charizard's potential and character development were not completely realized, it's clear that its powerful capabilities in battle made it a favorite among fans.

Some fans argue that Charizard's potential was not sufficiently explored, leading to a sense of missed opportunity. Its iconic status and the impact it had on Ash's journey further contribute to the sentiment that Ash should have kept it. However, the bond that Ash developed with Charizard and the numerous battles it participated in make it a difficult decision to consider Charizard's release as a regrettable move.

The Buttery Controversy

Another strong contender is Butterfree. As Ash's first Pokémon to evolve and his first release, the evolution and the subsequent battle between Ash and Misty in the Johto region was an emotional moment that many fans will remember. Despite its significance, the fact that Butterfree's release was permanent and did not return has been a point of contention among fans.

Fans often lament the emotional weight of releasing Butterfree, emphasizing their attachment to the Pokémon. Butterfree's evolution and later temporary departure during the Firefighting Tournament further highlight the sense of loss and regret associated with its release.

Squirtle: The Underrated Choice

My second choice for a Pokémon Ash should have kept is Squirtle. The Squirtle Squad, featuring Squirtle, Turtwig, and Runta, had performed exceptionally well throughout the series. It was illogical for Ash to release Squirtle given the team's success without him. For the duration of the Firefighting Tournament, Squirtle could have stayed to provide additional assistance to the team.

Additionally, Bulbasaur could have been a contender for keeping, as his reasons for being left behind seemed too convenient. Keeping either Squirtle or Bulbasaur would have allowed Ash to have a more balanced team and maintain a strong bond with his Pokémon.

Grinnedia: The Controversial Choice

The optimal choice for a Pokémon Ash should have kept, according to some fans, is one of his Alola Pokémon. Greninja, in particular, stands out as a strong candidate. Greninja has a special connection with Ash and is often considered his strongest Pokémon, often winning battles without much effort. The fan-favorite Pokémon has been seen in almost every battle, and its inclusion in Ash's original team would have been a significant plus.

Other Alolan Pokémon include Incineroar, Rowlet, and Lycanroc. While Incineroar never had a battle after evolving, and Rowlet and Lycanroc were Ash's ace Pokémon, Greninja's presence and its special relationship with Ash make it a compelling candidate for keeping.

Conclusion

The debate over which Pokémon Ash should have kept is a multifaceted issue rooted in the emotional connection between trainer and Pokémon. While Charizard, Butterfree, Squirtle, and Greninja are the most commonly discussed, other Pokémon such as Bulbasaur and Incineroar also factor into the discussion. The decision to release or keep a Pokémon greatly depends on the balance of the team and the emotional attachment to each Pokémon.

Ultimately, the feelings towards these Pokémon are subjective, but they are undeniably significant in shaping Ash's journey in the Pokémon anime. Fans and enthusiasts continue to explore these choices, adding depth and richness to the love story between trainer and Pokémon.