The Dilemma of Becoming Evil: Is Evil Morty the Original Morty?

In the popular animated series Rick and Morty, the character of Morty Smith has multiple incarnations across different dimensions. However, one iteration that stands out is Evil Morty, a version who has embraced a darker destiny than the original Morty. This article explores the complexities of Evil Morty's role, his origins, and whether he might be the true Morty we've come to know.

The Origins and Nature of Evil Morty

Evil Morty, a character hailing from the animated series Rick and Morty, is a distinct version of Morty Smith who has become disillusioned with his role in the ever-repeating cycle of relationships between Rick (Rick Sanchez) and Morty across different dimensions. His character represents a more complex and darker take on the Morty archetype, seeking freedom from the control and manipulation that come with the dynamics between Rick and Morty.

Evolving Motivations and Backstories

The episode Id is often cited as a pivotal moment in Evil Morty's development. In one of Rick and Morty's classic adventures, things take a tragic turn. Rick overhears Morty making a fatal prediction and, in desperation, leaves his reality to find one where he had left his wife, Beth, 20 years prior. Without Morty, Rick cannot stay in this reality, but as he cannot face the potential loss of Morty, he creates a new reality where he tries to avoid the moment by leaving early.

However, Morty survives in this new timeline, and his survival comes at a cost. Angering over the absence of Rick and the shift in his reality, Morty becomes bitter and eventually evil. His hatred for Rick, particularly C137 Rick, leads him to take revenge and blow up the lighthouse, killing both himself and Rick to escape the situation. This act is not cold and calculated, but driven by anger and despair.

Comparing Original Morty and Evil Morty

The actions of Evil Morty are far more cold and calculated, often driven by plans and a grander scheme. His desire for vengeance and control is clear. In contrast, the original Morty from C137 is often portrayed as a more emotionally-driven character. Morty has done things that come from a place of emotion, care, and compassion, such as killing the lighthouse keeper and villagers out of anger, shooting Rick, and disfiguring Ethan because Ethan was mean to Summer. Even in these moments, however, Morty's actions are rooted in feelings of hurt and protectiveness.

Despite the similarities in their actions, there is a critical difference in their motivations. While Morty is often driven by raw emotions and a desire to protect what he loves, Evil Morty's actions are more strategic and driven by a desire for control and retribution. Evil Morty could, in theory, kill his family without a second thought, which underscores the fundamental difference between them.

The Idea of a Secret Twin Brother

Despite the stark differences, some fans have suggested that the original Morty might be a secret twin brother or another version of Evil Morty. This theory proposes that Morty, with his adaptable and often rebellious nature, might have gone through the same transformations as Evil Morty but in a different timeline. This idea suggests that Morty's emotional and deeper connection to his family could simply be a different manifestation of the same core character who, in other scenarios, could embody the characteristics of Evil Morty.

Supporters of this theory argue that Morty has gone on many adventures and experienced various traumas that could have led to a transformation similar to that of Evil Morty. However, unlike Evil Morty, Morty's decisions are often driven by a deep-seated love and care for his family and friends.

Conclusion

The question of whether Evil Morty could be the original Morty remains open and speculative. While there is no concrete evidence to support such a theory, it highlights the complex and multifaceted nature of the Morty character in Rick and Morty. The differences in their motivations and actions underscore the depth of the series and the possibility of alternate realities shaping different versions of the same character.

As the series continues to explore the realms of science fiction and the complexity of human nature, fans are left to ponder: Is Evil Morty the original Morty, and if not, where do we draw the line between the two?

Keywords: Rick and Morty, Evil Morty, Original Morty