The Great Debate: Darkseid or Thanos?

When discussing the portrayal of godlike beings in DC Comics (DCEU) and Marvel, the question often arises: Is Darkseid the DC version of Thanos? This article explores the origins and development of both characters, addressing the common misconception that Darkseid is derived from Thanos, and highlighting why Darkseid stands alone as a formidable entity in his own right.

Origins of Darkseid and Thanos

Most assume that Thanos, an imposing figure with a lust for cosmic power, is the DC version of the DC Comics character Darkseid. However, a careful examination of the history reveals a different story. Darkseid, the Lord of Apokolips, first appeared in Forever People #1 in 1971, while Thanos made his first appearance in Thor #395 in 1973. Contrary to popular belief, Darkseid predates Thanos by nearly two years, making him the original and more enduring version of an anti-heroic ruler.

Jim Starlin and the Creation of Thanos

While Jack Kirby created Darkseid, it was Jim Starlin who brought Thanos to life at Marvel. Starlin was influenced by Kirby's work, particularly Darkseid. In an interview, Starlin admitted that the design of Thanos was indeed inspired by Darkseid. However, Starlin had other characters in mind initially, with Metron being one of them. Roy Thomas, Thanos's editor, encouraged Starlin to base Thanos on Darkseid when reworking the character. This led to Thanos taking on traits reminiscent of DC characters, but his essence remains uniquely his own.

Character Traits and Contrasts

Despite the influence, Darkseid and Thanos have distinct characteristics. Darkseid, a New God and ruler of Apokolips, seeks the Anti-Life Equation to conquer the universe. His motivations are rooted in his desire for ultimate control and power. In contrast, Thanos is a Titan, all-powerful but driven by his love for the personification of death, Death herself. While both characters wield immense power, their ideological and thematic differences make them unique entities in their respective universes.

The Evolution of Darkseid

Darkseid's character has evolved significantly over the years. In the modern Marvel reboots, particularly in Action Comics #1038 (2021), Darkseid resurfaces as a formidable force. This resurgence marks a return to his roots and highlights the character's enduring appeal as a villain.

Conclusion

The misconception that Thanos is the DC version of Darkseid stems from the influence of one creator on another. While Jim Starlin's Thanos was partly inspired by Kirby's Darkseid, Darkseid remains a character of his own entity. His creation by Jack Kirby and his enduring presence in comics, alongside his recent resurgence in modern storylines, underscore his significance as a central figure in the DC universe.

For those interested in the depth and impact of these iconic characters, exploring their origins and evolution can provide a richer understanding of the DC and Marvel universes.