The Impact of an All-Black Superman: A Critical Analysis of Future DC Releases

Introduction

Given the recent rumors of a potential all-black Superman, it is crucial to explore the potential repercussions on the DC Extended Universe (DCEU). While some may view this as a groundbreaking step towards inclusivity, others argue it risks alienating existing fans or merely pandering to a specific demographic. This article delves into the implications of this shift and questions the wisdom of such a move.

Potential Breakdown of the DCEU

The rumor of an all-black Superman, while intriguing, may have profound consequences for the DCEU. This change, if implemented, should be approached with caution. It's not just about the skin color of Superman, but more about aligning with what fans really want. Reducing the focus on Zack Snyder's vision could lead to a significant overhaul of the established narrative.

Alternative Characters Suggested

Instead of rebooting for a black Superman, other characters like Steel could provide a richer narrative. John Henry Irons, also known as Steel, is a compelling candidate for a standalone story. His background as a brilliant and morally conflicted engineer, coupled with his superheroic efforts, makes him a strong alternative to a traditional Superman reboot.

Expanding on John Henry Irons' Character

Steel's story could complement the Superman narrative. During an earthquake, Irons saves Superman, and later, when he sees the impact of his actions, he builds a technological suit to honor Superman. This character embodies the essence of a superhero grounded in human struggle and intelligence, making him an appealing protagonist for a movie.

Why Steel Over Black Superman

Championing Steel offers a way to introduce diversity without diluting the core values of the DCEU. It allows for a narrative that resonates with a broader audience, avoiding the pitfalls of alienating existing fans. An all-black Superman might be a superficial nod to diversity, but a Steel movie offers deeper thematic exploration and character development.

Revisiting Previous Mistakes

The reason behind bringing Supergirl into the movies is a missed opportunity. Her presence could have enhanced the narrative and provided a different perspective on the Kryptonian mythos. The story of Kara Zor-El, the cousin of Kal-El, although intriguing, is not as accessible or relatable as several other narratives within the DCEU.

Addressing Zack Snyder's Mistakes

Revisiting the concept of Superman's kryptoforming and the Kryptonian outpost from the Age of Space Expansion offers a more nuanced and interesting narrative. Correcting these mistakes and presenting an alternative storyline could provide a richer, more engaging storyline. Reinforcing the human aspects of kryptonian physiology shifts the focus to a more inclusive and diverse perspective.

Conclusion

In summary, while the idea of an all-black Superman is intriguing, it may not be the most effective or impactful way to move forward for the DCEU. Instead, focusing on characters like Steel provides a compelling and relevant narrative that can resonate with a wide audience. The key is to ensure that any changes align with the core values and narrative strengths of the DCEU, rather than merely pandering to a specific demographic.