Understanding the Complexity of Lily and Snape’s Friendship

A common misinterpretation in the Harry Potter universe surrounds the relationship between Lily Evans and Severus Snape. Many people claim that Snape was the most terrible friend, while Lily stuck by him despite his harmful actions. This narrative is not only misguided but also fails to consider the actual nuances of their friendship and the complexity of their interactions.

Myth vs. Reality: Severus Snape’s Allegiance to Lily

There is a misconception that Severus Snape respected Lily’s wishes and deliberately stayed away from her. Contrary to this belief, it is evident that Snape did not stay away from Lily out of respect; rather, he may have chosen to avoid her because of his own vulnerabilities and hidden motives. Snape’s actions were often influenced by his own personal beliefs and ideals, rather than his respect for Lily's decisions.

A Deeper Look: Lily's Unwavering Support

Lily did not want to end her relationship with Snape. She chose to give him numerous chances and ignored the rumors and warnings from her friends. Her actions were driven by a hope that Snape would change and prove them wrong. For years, Lily turned a blind eye to his actions, offering him opportunities to explain himself and make excuses. Her unwavering support stemmed from a deep-seated belief in the possibility of their friendship.

Metaphorical Comparison: The Cranky Crush Case

To better understand Lily’s and Snape’s situation, consider a metaphorical scenario. Imagine you have a crush on a specific girl but hate her entire race. You even dream of joining a terrorist organization that subjugates or erases that race. Yet, you decide to befriend this girl because there are no better options in your area. Once you enter school, you find like-minded people with whom you enjoy spending time, but you start to take the girl for granted, even when she presents you with ultimatums to choose between her and the terrorist group.

The Tragic Outcome: Choosing Evil Over Friendship

Suppose this girl presents an ultimatum, forcing you to choose between her and the terrorist organization. You choose the latter, severing your friendship with the girl. Despite the girl’s attempts to help you see the error of your ways, you fail to make amends. After graduating, you join the terrorist organization, becoming a top member and part of your boss’s inner circle. Many innocents paid the price for your actions, including those you once knew and cared about.

This metaphor serves to highlight how Lily and Snape’s story mirrors this tragic outcome, but also underscores the importance of not twisting or misinterpreting their interactions. Both characters had complex motivations, and their decisions were deeply influenced by their own demons and beliefs.

Conclusion: The Harmful Impact of Misunderstanding Friendships

In conclusion, the portrayal of Lily and Snape’s friendship is often distorted due to a lack of understanding of the complexity involved. It is crucial to approach such narratives with a critical eye and avoid misinterpreting dialogues and actions. Both Lily and Snape deserve to be judged based on their own decisions, motivations, and actions, not on preconceived notions or oversimplified narratives.