What If Tyrion Chose Jon Snow as His Champion in Game of Thrones?

In the richly layered universe of Game of Thrones, every character has a unique place and significance. One intriguing 'what if' scenario involves Tyrion Lannister choosing Jon Snow as his champion for trial by combat. This hypothetical situation presents a fascinating gameplay strategy and a potential shift in the story's dynamics.

Threat and Counter-Strategy

The Mountain would have still died, but this time, quicker. This is not due to Overton Power advantages, but to Jon's tactical prowess and strategic mindset. The Mountain, much like a tank, possesses immense force and power but lacks agility and finesse. Jon's abilities, on the other hand, may be less about brute strength and more about wit and cunning – crucial traits for a trial by combat.

The scenario gives us an interesting insight into why Jon might not have been the first choice to serve the Mountain. Despite Jon's physical strength, his strategic and mental capabilities could potentially lead to an unexpected twist that could turn the tide of the battle.

Character Relationships and Preferences

Jon respected Tyrion and understood his intellect. It's plausible that if Tyrion had the authority to select a Black Brother as champion, Jon might have accepted the role. However, Jon's skills are well-matched with those of the Mountain, making the outcome uncertain and intriguing.

The Consequences of Choosing Jon

Had Jon taken up the challenge, he would likely have been easily defeated or killed. Despite being a man of honor and a formidable fighter, Jon's tactical approach and reliance on fair play may make him vulnerable in a tit-for-tit combat scenario. The Mountain's sheer brute strength could easily overwhelm Jon's strategic advantages. This could have far-reaching consequences, as Jon Snow would no longer be a civilian but a marked man, potentially leading to his downfall or jailing.

Revised Storylines and Alternatives

The absence of Jon could significantly alter other storylines as well. For example, Sansa Stark would likely escape Winterfell and march north with her Vale army. However, their efforts would be futile against the harshness of the winter, and Sansa eventually might be killed or captured. The story of the wildlings also changes, as Jon's refusal to let them through the gates could have significant implications on their survival.

Other Potential Champions

But there are other characters who might have been more suitable for the challenge, such as:
Oberyn Martell: A brilliant and fiercely loyal character, Oberyn would bring his unwavering support and unique flair to the battle. Wearing a helmet, he could add an extra layer of unpredictability to his fighting style. Bronn: Known for his strategic mind and cunning, Bronn would have made a powerful ally for Tyrion, defeating a variety of opponents through his wits. Khal Drogo: As a skilled and respected conqueror, Khal Drogo might have offered a formidable option, combining physical prowess with a psychological edge.

Each of these characters brings a unique set of skills and behaviors that could have altered the course of the trial by combat, adding an exciting element of unpredictability to the narrative.

The Legal and Political Implications

It's also worth noting that the Crown would likely not permit Jon to participate in such a trial, given the rules of the Night's Watch and the political dynamics. Additionally, the Mountain's defeat would eliminate one of the last Targaryens, reprising the threat of the Targaryen bloodline and the potential of a new Targaryen rebellion.

Conclusion

The hypothetical scenario of Tyrion choosing Jon as a champion for trial by combat introduces an array of complex strategies, strategic decisions, and unforeseen outcomes. It challenges our understanding of character abilities and the intricate dynamics within the Game of Thrones universe. While this scenario may not have been the most practical, it certainly adds an element of excitement and intrigue to the narrative, bringing into question the true nature of strength and victory in a trial by combat.