Why All Might Chose Izuku over Mirio as His Successor

In the world of heroes, the decision to choose a successor is not just a minor detail but a critical one. Consider the unique case of All Might and his choice between Mirio Himiko and Izuku Midoriya as his next hero. This article delves into the reasons behind All Might's choice and the complexities involved in selecting a successor.

The Recommendation and the Decision

Nighteye, All Might’s old sidekick, recommended Mirio Himiko as the potential successor. Nighteye had been training Mirio for years, hoping that he would prove to be the right choice. However, All Might ultimately decided to visit U.A. High School and meet Izuku Midoriya instead. Was All Might’s decision influenced by Nighteye’s recommendation, or did he choose what he truly believed was best?

The Decision That Counts

All Might's decision to choose Izuku over Mirio was a deeply personal one. The holder of the One for All (OFA) quirk has unparalleled insight into what a potential successor should embody. While Nighteye's recommendation carried significant weight, it ultimately was All Might's intuition and belief that shaped his decision.

The Impact of Bakugo

Interestingly, All Might mentioned during a later encounter that the day he met Izuku, he had initially planned to meet Mirio in Ymir. Izuku's selfless act to save Bakugo was the turning point that influenced All Might’s choice. All Might could empathize with Izuku's desire to be a hero, given his own heritage as a quirkless person. This connection undoubtedly played a pivotal role in his final decision.

Mirio's Potential Wasn't the Only Factor

Though Mirio Himiko was the best option when All Might was initially considering a successor, he was not deemed the most deserving. Izuku Midoriya’s journey and actions, especially his heroic act to save Bakugo, demonstrated his readiness and willingness to fulfill the role of a hero. The story highlights how personality, morals, and actions are far more important than a pre-recommended candidate.

Conclusion: The Choice is Ultimately Personal

In the end, All Might's choice of successor is a testament to the complexity of the decision-making process. Nighteye's recommendation was significant, but it was All Might's own experiences and beliefs that ultimately led him to choose Izuku. This case study underscores the importance of trust, personal judgment, and the unique qualities that make a hero.

Quirks aside, the choice of a successor is a personal journey of introspection and understanding. All Might's story serves as a reminder that sometimes, the best choice is the one that resonates most deeply with the heart of the one who holds the power to choose.