Why Did Grisha Yeager Not Reveal the Truth in Attack on Titan?

The decision by Grisha Yeager to withhold the truth about the world outside the Walls from the Eldians in Attack on Titan is a complex one, rooted in multifaceted motivations. This article delves into the rationale behind Grisha’s choices, exploring the various reasons that shaped his decision and the impact it had on the Eldian people.

1. Fear of Chaos and Panic

One of the primary reasons Grisha Yeager did not reveal the truth to the Eldians was the potential for widespread panic and chaos. Grisha believed that the people inside the Walls were not emotionally or mentally prepared to handle the overwhelming information about the Titans, the world beyond the Walls, and the existence of Marley. He feared that divulging such truth could lead to mass hysteria, undermining the stability and unity of the Eldian society. This aligns with the well-documented principle that sudden, unexpected revelations can cause widespread distress and social upheaval.

2. Protecting Eren’s Mission

Grisha’s paramount concern was the safeguarding of Eren Yeager so that he could fulfill his destiny. As the father of Eren and the reputed savior, Grisha believed that Eren’s mission to liberate the Eldians from the Marleyan oppression required him to be shielded from the full burden of knowledge. By not revealing the truth, Grisha aimed to ensure that Eren remained focused on his primary objective without being sidetracked by the complexities of the world outside the Walls. This mirrors the protective instincts often seen in parents and guardians who believe that knowledge amassed through experience is more powerful and less damaging when integrated over time.

3. Belief in Fate

Grisha’s philosophy was deeply rooted in the belief in fate and destiny. He strongly believed that Eren was predestined to play a crucial role in the future of the Eldians and Marley. Grisha’s faith in the inevitability of Eren’s destiny led him to believe that revealing the truth too soon could distract him from his ultimate mission. In this context, Grisha’s actions can be seen as a reflection of his deep-seated belief that the truth will be discovered in due time, when Eren is ready to embrace it. This belief underscores the broader theme of Attack on Titan which explores the interplay between fate, free will, and the role of individuals in shaping their own destiny.

4. Urgency for Change

Grisha’s experiences as a Marleyan and his involvement in the Eldian Restorationist movement gave him a profound sense of urgency for change. He saw Eren as the key figure who could lead the Eldians to freedom, but he believed that this could only be achieved if Eren fully embraced his role without the additional burden of the truth. Grisha’s actions can be interpreted as a calculated strategy to empower Eren, believing that Eren would be more effective in his mission if he did not carry the weight of the outside world’s complexities. This aligns with leadership philosophies that advocate for focused and directed leadership, where leaders shield their followers from unnecessary distractions until the critical moment arrives.

5. Mistrust of Others

Another reason for Grisha’s decision to withhold the truth could stem from a lack of trust in others within the Walls. Given Grisha’s past as a Marleyan and his experiences with the Eldian people, he may have been concerned about the reliability and loyalty of those who held power. Grisha had likely seen first-hand the negative consequences of fear and misinformation, and he may have been wary of how others might exploit the knowledge of the outside world for their own selfish gains. This mistrust further underscores the political and social dynamics within the Eldian society and the intricate power structures that influence decision-making.

Conclusion

In summary, Grisha Yeager’s decision to not reveal the truth was driven by a complex mix of protective instincts, faith in fate, a desire to prepare Eren for his future role, and a belief in the urgency for change. His actions reflect a deep understanding of the emotional and psychological impact of sudden revelations, and a strategic approach to ensuring that Eren is ready to face the challenges that lie ahead. The decision to withhold the truth, though highly problematic, was rooted in a profound belief in the potential power of knowledge, both as an enabler and a burden.