Why Tarkin Did Not Kill Palpatine with the Death Star

In the expansive and intricate web of the Star Wars universe, the decision of Grand Moff Wilhuff Tarkin not to use the Death Star to kill Emperor Palpatine is a complex one. This article delves into the motivations and reasons behind Tarkin's actions, focusing on his loyalty, the political power dynamics, and his own beliefs as a Sith and Imperial commander.

Loyalty and Ambition

Tarkin's primary motivations stemmed from his unwavering loyalty to Emperor Palpatine and his ambitious aspirations within the Imperial hierarchy. Throughout the saga, Tarkin displayed a deep commitment to the Emperor's vision for the Galactic Empire. His loyalty was not just a facade but a genuine belief in the Emperor's leadership and the Empire's cause. As a general and a military man, Tarkin saw himself as a follower of a greater mission, aligning his personal ambitions with those of the Emperor. This belief in the Emperor's vision, combined with his ambition for advancement, made any thoughts of assassination inconceivable.

Political Power Dynamics

The power dynamics within the Empire are crucial to understanding Tarkin's decision. Palpatine, as the supreme leader of the Galactic Empire, held ultimate authority. Tarkin, despite his vast powers and influence, was still a subordinate in the Imperial hierarchy. Attempting to kill the Emperor would be a monumental risk, not just politically but personally. It could have resulted in his own demise or severe punishment, making such a move deeply un advisable. Tarkin's loyalty to Palpatine ensured that he respected and abided by the Emperor's orders, even if it meant deferring to him on matters of life and death.

Role of the Death Star

The Death Star, with its immense destruction capabilities, served as a potent symbol of the Empire's dominance. Tarkin believed in using the Death Star as a means to enforce the Emperor's rule, rather than as a weapon to eliminate him. The massive battlestation was designed to strike fear into the hearts of those who opposed the Empire, reinforcing Palpatine's power and maintaining the order he had established. Tarkin saw the Death Star as a tool to demonstrate the Emperor's might, not as a means to overthrow him. This belief was deeply rooted in his understanding of the role he played in the Empire's success.

Trust and Leadership

Tarkin's trust in the Emperor's leadership was another critical factor. He likely viewed Palpatine as a necessary figure in maintaining order in the galaxy. The Emperor's manipulative skills and political acumen were seen as essential for the stability of the Empire. Despite Palpatine's manipulations and political savviness, Tarkin believed that these qualities were critical for the Empire's survival and function. This trust in the Emperor's leadership made it inherently difficult for Tarkin to consider any action that could disrupt the delicate balance of power within the Empire.

Tarkin's Different Nature

Contrary to the stereotypical depiction of Imperials as power-hungry and deceitful, Tarkin was a unique individual. He was a sociopath who was genuinely dedicated to serving the Sith God and the Emperor. Unlike other Imperials, Tarkin was not driven by fear, greed, or the desire to cause chaos. He was an evil being who believed that murdering people and ruling through fear was the correct path for the galaxy. He thought that this was the best way to maintain order and did not care about the well-being of those deemed weak. His motivations were not based on delusion or being manipulated; he sincerely believed in the righteousness of the Emperor and the Empire.

What if Palpatine Died?

Should the Emperor have died, Tarkin's response would have been a matter of loyalty and duty. If there was no direct successor equal to Palpatine, Tarkin would likely feel it was his duty to carry on the Emperor's will and plan. Without someone with Palpatine's authority and influence, Tarkin, as one of the most powerful and influential figures in the Empire, would naturally gravitate towards maintaining the status quo. He would see it as his responsibility to ensure that the Emperor's vision and plans were continued until a new successor could be identified and brought to power.

In conclusion, Tarkin's decision not to use the Death Star to kill Palpatine was deeply rooted in his loyalty to the Emperor, the political dynamics of the Empire, and his belief in the righteousness of their cause. His actions may seem misguided to some, but they were driven by a compelling set of beliefs and principles that shaped his understanding of the galaxy's order.

Sources:

Star Wars: A New Hope Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back Star Wars: Return of the Jedi Star Wars: The Clone Wars (Animated Series)