Would Grindelwald Have Defeated the Aurors if Newt's Bird Didn’t Tip the Scale?

In the Harry Potter series, particularly in Order of the Phoenix, we see characters like Albus Dumbledore and Grindelwald showcase their immense magical prowess. Grindelwald, in particular, is often portrayed as the most powerful dark wizard to have ever existed, with only Albus Dumbledore matching him in strength. Given this backdrop, one fascinating question arises: would Grindelwald have triumphed over the Aurors if Newt Scamander's creature didn’t intervene?

Grindelwald’s Strength and Record of Victory

The evidence that supports the likelihood of Grindelwald defeating the Aurors is clear from the champions’ dialogue. In Order of the Phoenix, when the disguised Dumbledore faces off against Cornelius Fudge and his cronies, he easily overcomes them, even when his secret is revealed. Similarly, at the Department of Mysteries, Dumbledore effortlessly neutralizes the Death Eaters with an Anti-Disapparation Jinx.

Grindelwald’s Demonstrated Prowess

Grindelwald’s own history provides further support. In the original novel and surrounding canon, Grindelwald is introduced as a formidable opponent. He effortlessly defeats many of his foes with little apparent struggle. For instance, in Deathly Hallows, we witness him defeating both Tina Goldstein and Newt Scamander's magical creature in a single exchange. His strategic and tactical superiority is well-documented through his victories over numerous magical beings in his lifetime.

Context of the Scene with Graves

When the scene with Graves occurs, we see him moving confidently down the platform, confronting the Aurors head-on. Despite the rapid-fire spells thrown at him from all directions, Graves deftly parries each and every one, sending several Aurors flying. This highlights his mastery over magical combat and strategic thinking, traits often attributed to Grindelwald.

Strengths and Conditions of a Battle

Grindelwald's superior skill in magical combat and strategic thinking suggests that even if the same scenario occurred, he would have the upper hand. Had Newt and Tina not intervened, Graves (or Grindelwald, if we assume he is a representation of Grindelwald’s abilities) would likely have prevailed. This is especially true if we consider that Grindelwald has shown himself to be almost invincible in previous battles against lesser opponents.

Concluding Thoughts

Given Grindelwald’s unmatched magical prowess and demonstrated ability to overcome formidable opponents, it is reasonable to conclude that he would have defeated the Aurors if the circumstances had been different. The scenario presented in the Harry Potter series demonstrates that magical combat is often as much about mental fortitude and strategic thinking as it is about raw power. Even with these lesser barriers, he would have been more than capable of achieving victory.

Keywords: Grindelwald, Aurors, Order of the Phoenix, Harry Potter, magical combat, strategic thinking, overwhelming power

Back to Top