Would Lena Luthor Be Kara's Enemy or Allies in Supergirl?

When it comes to the dynamic between Kara Zor-El and Lena Luthor on the show Supergirl, the question of whether they should be allies or enemies is a fascinating one. This relationship has been the driving force of many compelling storylines and adds depth to the narrative. In this article, we explore the potential benefits and drawbacks of either scenario, ultimately concluding that a mixture of mistrust and camaraderie would be the most entertaining and nuanced option for the characters.

Why Allies?

The partnership between Kara and Lena is not only beneficial for the storyline but also for character development. Lena Luthor’s interactions with Kara provide a stark contrast to Kara’s more optimistic and carefree nature. Her intelligence and wit offer a refreshing pause in the superhero drama, allowing the plot to breathe and delve into more complex moral issues.

Moreover, Lena’s intricate balance between good and evil serves as a mirror to Kara’s pure-heartedness. This duality enriches the show, offering a more realistic take on what it means to be a hero in a world filled with moral ambiguities. As Lena once said, 'Some problems can only be solved by the most over-the-top and involved schemes with awesome side effects for the rest of the world,' highlighting the Luthor’s razor approach to issues.

Why Enemies?

On the flip side, it's interesting to imagine a scenario where Kara and Lena become adversaries. This could indeed introduce conflict and tension, but it might also simplify the narrative at a time when the Luthors are already struggling with their own moral dilemmas. Transforming Lena into a traditional villain would mean sacrificing the complexity and richness of her character, which many viewers have come to appreciate.

The Ideal Scenario: Allies with a Side of Distrust

The ideal solution, in my opinion, is for Kara and Lena to remain allies while maintaining a degree of distrust. This approach provides the best of both worlds, combining the benefits of a strategic partnership with the ongoing tension that keeps the audience engaged. The Luthors, like the Kents and the Doms, are a family defined by their intellect and humanity, but also by their secrets and flaws.

The relationship between Kara and Lena is often characterized by the push and pull of their respective personalities. Kara’s trust in the Luthors, while sometimes misplaced, allows for genuine moments of connection and understanding. Lena, on the other hand, harbors her own secrets and uncertainties, which contribute to the overall intrigue of their relationship. Their complex history and the ever-present element of mistrust create a dynamic that fuels the narrative and keeps the audience invested in their story.

Furthermore, the occasional revelation about Lena’s involvement with the Supergirl identity adds an extra layer of complexity. This dynamic is both frustrating and thrilling, as viewers watch Lena navigate the moral grey zone, often making choices that Kara finds unsettling. This contrast, where one character is light and fluffy, and the other is dark and morally ambiguous, creates a fascinating dichotomy that resonates with audiences.

Conclusion

The relationship between Kara and Lena Luthor is one of the most compelling aspects of the show Supergirl. Maintaining a balance between allies and enemies, while adding a layer of distrust and complexity to their interactions, would be the best way to keep the narrative exciting and morally enriching. This approach allows both characters to shine and evolve, offering a more satisfying and nuanced viewing experience.