Yeagerists vs. The Alliance in Attack on Titan: A Critical Analysis

Attack on Titan (AoT) presents a complex moral and political dilemma through its narrative and character portrayals. This article explores the arguments of both the Yeagerists and the Alliance, offering an in-depth analysis based on the information provided and broader interpretations of the series.

Understanding the Conflict

The conflict in Attack on Titan revolves around the Eldians, who are both the creators and victims of the society they live in. Marley, the embodiment of Eldian oppression, attacked Paradis during seasons 1-3, leading to the destruction of two of the three walls. Prior to that, Marley had engaged in a four-year war against nations that did not oppress the Eldians, including the Hizuru alliance.

While Paradis was isolated, the rest of the Eldian world faced extinction at the hands of Marley and Hizuru. This isolation makes the conversation about defending Paradis from a group with no contact a moot point, juxtaposed with the.EntityManager's history of aggression and violence.

The Role of Titans and Humanity

The series questions the nature of becoming a monster oneself. The fight against Titans is a fight against one's own humanity. The world and the people on Paradis face a shared nightmare, and it is this mutual suffering that changes the moral landscape. The world does not deserve to be saved, but the people do.

The Yeagerists' Stand

The Yeagerists, led by Zeke Yeager, embody a deep-seated need for vengeance and justice. They believe that one's sins must be reflected back, a form of retribution and closure. The world, particularly Marley, has committed unforgivable sins through the creation of negative stereotypes and the promotion of hatred.

The Yeagerists' argument hinges on the idea that all racial and ethnic cleansing and oppression must be addressed. Their actions are seen as an attempt to pay back the debt owed by Marley to the Eldians. The Yeagerists' perspective aligns with a belief that every country has a past, and no nation can escape its history of wrongdoing.

The Alliance's Goals

In contrast, the Alliance consists of nations that did not participate in the Eldian wars but wish to promote peace and unity. Their goal is to construct a society where the Eldian and Marleyan conflict no longer exists. However, their approach is seen as a temporary solution, lacking the strength and resolve to permanently protect Paradis from the Eldian threat.

The Yeagerists argue that the Alliance's approach is too weak and insufficient. They view the Alliance as a flag of temporary peace that can be easily changed. This perspective challenges the very notion that a lasting peace can be achieved without addressing the root causes of past conflicts.

A Critique of Both Stances

Both the Yeagerists and the Alliance have valid points, yet both have their flaws. The Yeagerists' crusade for revenge and purification may lead to further suffering, while the Alliance's approach may be too accommodating.

The series poses an interesting question: can true peace be achieved through retribution and revenge, or is it more viable to focus on reconciliation and mutual understanding?

Ultimately, Attack on Titan invites viewers to reflect on these complex ethical dilemmas, encouraging a deeper appreciation for the intricate web of history, morality, and human nature.

Perhaps the true goal should not be to save or destroy, but to rebuild and live together in harmony, understanding the shared suffering that binds us all.

Shinzou

WO

SASAGEYO!