Who Would Win: Annie as a Beast Titan or a Titan Shifter?

One of the most intriguing discussions within the Attack on Titan community revolves around the possibility of Annie Leonhart evolving into a Titan herself. In the renowned retelling of "If Annie Were a Titan", one of the most often-debated scenarios is Annie as a Beast Titan compared to her possible transformation as a Titan Shifter. This article will delve into the strengths and weaknesses of both scenarios and determine who would hold the upper hand.

Understanding the Beast Titan and Titan Shifters

The Beast Titan is one of the most powerful titans mentioned in the series. Unlike the Colossal and Armored Titans, its power lies in its sheer strength and the ability to harden its body. It is capable of effortlessly breaking through enemy lines and even armored titans, showcasing its dominance in combat.

Beast Titan: Unmatched Strength and Endurance

The Beast Titan is renowned for its raw power and durability. This titan has an incredible strength that allows it to break through defenses without taking significant damage. When the Beast Titan
confronts the Armored Titan, it is described as a fight where the Armored Titan barely receives any damage while the Beast Titan emerges unscathed. This showcases the Beast Titan's ability to break through defenses without absorbing any damage.

The Beast Titan's capability to throw boulders with such force that they can rip through the defenses of even powerful titans exemplifies its unwavering strength. This strength not only allows it to demolish fortifications but also to create significant damage in battle. Hence, the Beast Titan’s strength seems almost unmatched, especially in confrontations with other titans.

Titans Shifting: Variance and Rudimentary Control

Titans shifting, on the other hand, involves humans with innate abilities transforming into corporeal titans. Typically, the transformations are incomplete and controlled to a limited extent. For example, Annie Leonhart as a Titan Shifter would possess the potential to manipulate her environment and use it as a weapon or shield. Even though her transformation is not complete, she could still benefit from these abilities.

Anne's Potential as a Beast Titan

Anne as a Beast Titan would inherit the same raw strength and durability as the original Beast Titan. She could harden her body, making herself impervious to most forms of physical damage. This would give her a significant advantage in battles, especially those involving heavily armored targets such as the Armored Titan. Anne's Beast Titan form would be highly effective in destroying fortifications and enemy lines, much like the original Beast Titan.

Titans Shifting and Anne's Limited Control

Anne as a Titan Shifter would have incomplete control, with her abilities being rudimentary and not fully forming. Her transformation might be similar to that of Ymir, the original Titan Shifter, allowing her to manipulate the environment around her but not to the extent of a fully formed Beast Titan. However, her Titan Shifter form could still prove to be a formidable weapon, with the potential to create obstacles and defend herself in combat.

Conclusion: Tailoring the Battle Scenario

Given the options, the Beast Titan form would be more advantageous for Annie. The Beast Titan's strength and durability make it nearly indestructible in battles involving other titans. It also has the versatility to throw boulders and harden its body, which provides multiple offensive and defensive options. In a hypothetical battle scenario, the Beast Titan would most likely emerge victorious.

On the other hand, while Anne's Titan Shifter form offers control over the environment and the potential to create obstacles, its incomplete transformation and limited control would make it less effective in combat compared to the Beast Titan form.

Key Takeaways

The Beast Titan's raw power and durability make it an overwhelming force in combat, surpassing even other titans. Anne's Beast Titan form would provide her with more consistent and powerful abilities, making it the stronger option. As a Titan Shifter, Anne's control and abilities would be limited, making her a less formidable opponent in a direct battle with titans.

Therefore, it can be concluded that Annie as a Beast Titan would hold the upper hand in a hypothetical battle scenario, outperforming the traditional Titan Shifter form.