Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood vs. The Original - A Comparative Analysis

Introduction

The vast and widely loved Fullmetal Alchemist universe has two significant adaptations - Fullmetal Alchemist (FMA) and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (FMB). Both series delve into parallel yet unique storylines, much like our own reality and its alternate counterparts. This article explores the differences between these two iconic series, offering insights for both fans and newcomers alike. You have been warned; some spoilers ahead!

Key Differences

Character Outcomes

A significant departure between FMA and FMB is seen in how character arcs are resolved. In the original Fullmetal Alchemist (FMA), Izumi Curtis tragically dies at the end of the series. In contrast, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (FMB) decides to bring back Izumi and Sig, depicting their return to peaceful lives after the final battle.

Homunculi Rearrangement

The transformation of characters into homunculi also presents stark differences. In FMA, Fuhrer Bradley was once a homunculus named Pride, while in FMB, Fuhrer Bradley is revealed to be the homunculus Wrath, making his identity more complex and intriguing. Similarly, in FMA, Sloth is Ed and Al's mother's homunculus, while in FMB, Sloth is introduced as a male homunculus of considerable size.

Key Movers and Shakers

A notable change in FMB is in the appearances and roles of key figures like May Chang and Ling Yao from the East, Father, the leader of the homunculi, and Olivier Mira Armstrong, who serves as the commander of the northern wall in FMB. In FMA, these characters either have shorter roles or are entirely absent, making their inclusion in FMB a significant addition to the narrative.

Shou Tucker and Scar's Actions

The aftermath for Shou Tucker is quite different in FMA and FMB. In FMA, Alphonse becomes a philosopher's stone, symbolizing the culmination of his alchemical sacrifices. However, in FMB, the characters never discover a perfect philosopher's stone. Instead, Tucker's fate is altered; he is killed by Scar shortly after attempting to alchemize his daughter and dog.

Final Battles and Conclusions

The ending of FMA sees Edward and Alphonse separated, with Edward returning to his world while Al remains trapped in the realm of FMA. This is dramatically different from FMB, where Al makes the ultimate sacrifice to save Edward, who then risks his life to reclaim it. This climactic twist changes the overall arc and legacy of the series significantly.

Epilogue and Movies

The epilogues of FMA and FMB further diverge. FMA concludes with a sense of open-endedness, setting the stage for potential sequels or spin-offs. In FMB however, the movie The Sacred Star of Milos serves as a bridge between the series and its conclusion, providing a more direct connection to the main story. Meanwhile, FMA has its own movie, The Conquerers of Shamballa, which explores an alternate storyline beyond the series.

Conclusion

While both Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood tell versions of the same story, the ways in which character arcs and storylines are resolved create distinct narratives and emotional journeys. Whether you embrace FMA or the FMB version, each series offers its unique flavor to the beloved Fullmetal Alchemist universe.