Is DC Comics Really Cancellation? A Closer Look at Superman and Supergirl

Introduction

The ever-evolving world of superhero comics can sometimes leave readers puzzled and even confused—especially when it comes to the cancellation of popular characters. DC Comics, known for its iconic titles and characters, has seen its fair share of title changes, cancellations, and timely revivals. In this article, we delve deep into the history of Superman and Supergirl, exploring the nuances of their titles, the reasons behind cancellations, and the enduring presence of these beloved characters in the DC Universe.

The Case of Supergirl: Endings and Revivals

Supergirl has a rich and varied history, much like Captain Marvel, which is why it's important to clarify the specific cases of cancellations and new beginnings. The most recent title, Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, actually concluded with issue 12. Given that it was a limited series, this conclusion was not due to a traditional cancellation but rather the natural end point of 12 issues as originally planned.

Supergirl’s other limited series, while ending with a final issue, have not been the subject of regular cancellations. She has, however, experienced a couple of ongoing series that have come to an abrupt end. This highlights the ongoing nature of comic book publishing, where storylines often reach predefined conclusions despite ongoing reader support and affection.

The Odyssey of Superman: From Heroes to Relaunches

Superman’s journey through DC Comics is a testament to the character's enduring popularity. The original Superman series, which began way back in 1939, came to a definitive end with issue 423 in 1986, marking the end of the golden era of comic storytelling. At this juncture, the title was changed to Adventures of Superman with issue 424, and a new Superman title began with 1.

Eventually, Adventures of Superman was cancelled with 650. A relaunch under the New 52 event in 2011 brought about a fresh start for the character. However, even this iteration faced its moment of closure, with the New 52 Superman series ending with issue 52. This was part of a broader DC Comics initiative to revitalize its entire line, which resulted in another reboot under the Rebirth banner in 2016.

During the Rebirth era, Superman had a run by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason that lasted 45 issues. This series was highly acclaimed, but ultimately, it too was cancelled to make way for a new series on the same title, this time helmed by Brian Michael Bendis. Bendis' run, while it lasted for 28 issues, was eventually cancelled with 32, signaling a significant shift in the direction of the Superman character.

Following the Bendis run, the focus shifted to Superman: Son of Kal-El and Action Comics, where Superman's son Jon Kent continued his adventures. Recently, however, there are plans to end Son of Kal-El with issue 18, although Jon is set to get a miniseries titled Jonathan Kent: Adventures of Superman. Additionally, a new Superman series is set to debut with issue 1, featuring his father once again.

Conclusion: The Eternal Legacy of Superman and Supergirl

No matter how many times these beloved characters are “cancelled,” they always find new ways to return to the forefront of DC Comics. While Superman and Supergirl have experienced varying cancellations, their enduring popularity ensures they remain central figures in the DC Universe. From limited series to ongoing runs, and from new titles to revivals, both characters continue to captivate audiences and shape the world of modern comic books.

Key Takeaways: Supergirl: Limited series often planned to conclude, not truly cancelled. Superman: Series have both experienced cancellations and successful relaunches. Endings and revivals are part of the evolving nature of comics, reflecting changes in storytelling and reader preferences.