Can We Finally Admit that Rick and Morty is Extremely Problematic?

Rick and Morty, though beloved by millions, has long been a subject of debate among fans and critics alike. Many have pointed out potential issues within the show, ranging from its dark humor and treatment of heavy themes to the portrayal of abusive relationships and the perpetuation of negative stereotypes.

Dark Humor and Heavy Themes

The show often tackles weighty and complex topics such as mental illness, existential dread, and trauma with a dark sense of humor. While this approach can be seen as a form of social commentary and artistic expression, some argue that it trivializes serious issues for comedic effect. For instance, how does one reconcile the use of confronting mental health and tragic life events as punchlines with the responsibility to respect and address these issues sensitively?

Character Portrayals and Relationships

The show’s portrayal of characters and their inter-relations is another area of contention. Fans have highlighted the often toxic dynamics, most notably Rick’s abusive behavior towards Morty and others. This has raised questions about the show’s stance on abusive relationships. Does it critique such behaviors or unwittingly endorse them? The show’s depiction of these relationships can have a profound impact on young viewers and may contribute to normalization of toxic dynamics in real life.

Sexist and Misogynistic Elements

Traits such as sexism and objectification of female characters are prevalent in the series. Critics argue that these instances can perpetuate a broader culture of misogyny, reinforcing harmful stereotypes and behaviors. Even in cases where female characters are not under stereotypical roles, their portrayal can still be seen as problematic, often reducing them to secondary or subservient roles.

The Nihilistic Outlook

The overarching theme of nihilism in the show has also been scrutinized. Some viewers and critics find the idea that nothing matters extremely disheartening and potentially harmful, especially to younger audiences. While the show may be viewed as a form of satirical social commentary, the pervasive sense of hopelessness and meaninglessness can be distressing.

What Morty and the Creators Think

Both Morty and the creators of the show have occasionally sparked discussions about their thoughts on these criticisms. In one scene, Summer states her disdain for interdimensional TV relying on juvenile violence, while Morty responds thoughtfully, suggesting that creators need not cater to every viewer’s sensibilities. He even goes as far as to argue that higher forms of existence would not be concerned with such trivialities, implying that those who cannot handle darker themes might not be ready for more evolved communication.

Another notable quote comes from the episode where Rick argues that depicting even the mention of depraved behavior must be pixellated out. This statement highlights the show’s awareness of its content and its intention to depict a morally complex world where such behaviors are not glorified or celebrated openly.

From this perspective, Rick and Morty is a show that stands as a masterclass in dark humor and complex storytelling. It challenges its viewers to ponder the ethical implications of the content, and whether the show is encouraging responsible storytelling and moral introspection or merely perpetuating harmful stereotypes and themes.