Unraveling the Accountability of Batman vs. Superman in the ‘Injustice’ Storyline

The Controversial Role of Batman and Superman

When discussing the 'Injustice' storyline, one topic that often arises is the accountability of Batman and Superman for certain events. Critics argue that Batman is the villain due to his 'leniency' towards dangerous criminal psychopaths, emphasizing that his leniency led to Lois Lane's death. However, the perception that Superman is the villain is also a significant point of debate. This article delves into the evidence and arguments surrounding both characters.

Understanding the 'Injustice' Storyline

In the 'Injustice' storyline, Batman and Superman's moral and ethical stances clash, leading to a complex narrative where both characters are portrayed in a less-than-positive light. Here are some key points:

Accounts of Batman's Leniency

Several characters in the 'Injustice' storyline blame Batman for the events that unfold, particularly the murder of Lois Lane by The Joker. The following list of characters agree with Superman and hold Batman responsible:

Superman Wonder Woman Flash Hal Jordan Shazam Dark Night (Damian Wayne) Aquaman Cyborg John Stewart (Green Lantern) Atom (Glen Moriak) Batman (Bruce Wayne)

Notably, Dick Grayson, once Robin, argues that Superman's actions were justified but remains heavily influenced by Batman. This influence is so strong that it results in selecting Batman as the villain over Superman, despite Superman's initial actions being morally questionable.

Superman's Actions and Blame

Superman, who initially holds Batman responsible, evolves into the central antagonist due to his authoritarian actions post-Joker's death. After killing the Joker, Superman begins implementing his regime and becomes the figure leading this authoritarian movement:

Superman's Regime: Superman enforces his rule and punishes those who oppose him, including Batman. His actions are seen as tyrannical and authoritarian. Manipulation by Diana: Superman's villainous journey is influenced significantly by Diana Prince, who manipulates him into an oppressive ruler. Had Superman not succumbed to Diana's manipulation, the storyline would have taken a different path.

Unfair Blame and Misconceptions

However, it is essential to consider why Batman cannot be held accountable in the same way as Superman. The 'Injustice' storyline presents several factors that mitigate Batman's responsibility:

Batman's No-Killing Rule

Batman has always adhered to a no-killing rule as a vigilante. This principle remains consistent in the 'Injustice' universe. When the Joker kills Robin (Jason Todd), Batman is advised against killing the Joker. Commissioner Gordon, whose family suffered at the Joker's hands, advises Batman to bring the Joker in alive.

Batman's decision to stop the Joker in The Killing Joke is a prime example of his hesitation to kill. Despite his personal emotional turmoil, Commissioner Gordon's advice prevails, and Batman chooses to apprehend the Joker.

Batman's role is to stop criminals, bring them to justice, and prevent further harm. If specific individuals disagree with his methods and want the offenders put to death, it is up to the court system and not Batman.

Responsibility Shifts to Others

While Superman is the central figure in the authoritarian regime, others also share the blame:

Wonder Woman and the War of the Gods: Her willingness to start a global conflict also contributed to the villainous atmosphere. Robin (Damian Wayne): Being on Superman's side and supporting his actions. The Regime: Any Regime member who willingly agrees to Superman's extreme measures.

Ultimately, the blame cannot solely be placed on Batman. His adherence to the no-killing rule and his mandate to maintain justice and order are pivotal aspects that differentiate his character from Superman's.

Conclusion

In the 'Injustice' storyline, both Batman and Superman face significant moral and ethical challenges. While Batman's leniency towards dangerous criminals is occasionally questioned, his adherence to a no-killing rule and his role in preventing harm mitigate his culpability. On the other hand, Superman's transformation into a tyrannical ruler and his manipulative actions significantly contribute to his villainous status.

Ultimately, understanding and contextualizing the 'Injustice' storyline reveals a more nuanced portrayal of both characters, emphasizing the importance of accountability and the complexities of moral choices in fiction.