Who Would Win: Rinnegan Nagato vs. Alive Sharingan Madara
Who Would Win: Rinnegan Nagato vs. Alive Sharingan Madara
In the world of Naruto, the Edo Tensei reappearance of Madara Uchiha and his Rinnegan symbolizes ultimate power. While Nagato Uzumaki's Rinnegan is a formidable opponent, the outcome of a battle between these two powerful figures remains a topic of heated debate among fans. This article will explore the capabilities and strengths of both characters and provide a comprehensive analysis to answer the question: who would win in a clash between Rinnegan Nagato and alive Sharingan Madara?
Nagato Uzumaki vs. Madara Uchiha: Regular Versus Full Mind Control
Typically, when people mention Nagato, they think of the version who was nearly overwhelmed by the team of Edo Itachi and Killer Bee under the full mind control of Kabuto Yakushi. This version of Nagato was weakened, indicating a significant disparity in capability compared to his uncontrolled self.
Uncontrolled Nagato: An Unstoppable Force
If the opponent is not Edo and not mind-controlled, the outcome is clear: Nagato stomps without question. His Rinnegan grants him the ability to see in every direction, allowing him to detect and counter any sneak attacks. Moreover, he can unleash wide-ranging chakra attacks and absorb all of Madara’s ninjutsu. In a direct confrontation, even if Madara manages to achieve an “instant kill,” Nagato can easily restore himself to full health.
Madara’s Advantages: Physical and Jutsu Knowledge
Madara’s primary advantages are his physical stats and jutsu knowledge. However, the effectiveness of jutsu is significantly diminished in this scenario. The intelligence of Madara, while not optimal for a “Warrior” class, is not the deciding factor in this battle. Madara prefers to take on his opponents head-on with sheer power and skill. Prior to the MS/EMS (Massive Shisui and Edo Mode Sharingan), Killer Bee and Kawarimi no Jutsu (Replacement Technique) Master (KCM1) Naruto would have easily defeated him.
Naruto’s Speed and Physical Superiority
Even with the MS/EMS and Senju Bloodline Limit, Madara’s physical strength is still unlikely to outclass the combined force of Killer Bee and KCM1 Naruto. Moreover, Naruto's speed and agility would make it difficult for Madara to gain the upper hand. The Rinnegan itself, especially in its full form, grants significant advantages that would make even a theoretical battle between them highly lopsided.
Pein's Influence on the Outcome
If we shift to the Pein-Nagato, where Pein provided the 6 Paths to assist in the battle against the living Madara, the outcome would be different. The Pein-Nagato would likely figure out the strategy of eliminating Madara's strongest body first, namely Madara's DS/MS (Demonic?? Mode Sharingan) body. From there, the Pein-Nagato could systematically overpower each of Madara's bodies individually.
Increased Odds: Edo Tensei's Influence
While the Pein-Nagato would still have a very good chance of winning, Madara would undoubtedly pull out some unconventional strategy to win. However, the Pein's influence and the 6 Paths of Pain would significantly tilt the odds in Rinnegan Nagato's favor.
Conclusion: The Ultimate Outcome
Given the analysis of both regular and controlled versions of Nagato, it is clear that the uncontrolled Nagato would easily triumph over alive Madara. However, the involvement of Pein and the 6 Paths of Pain might provide a more nuanced outcome, where Rinnegan Nagato has a formidable chance of winning, but Madara could still pull a surprise victory with his unparalleled strategic and tactical intellect.