Why the Star Wars Sequel Trilogy Fails to Impress: A Subjective Analysis

Star Wars, the franchise that once captivated audiences with its intricate storytelling, has seen a critical shift with the release of the sequel trilogy. Many view them as a disappointment, while others champion them. This article explores the reasons behind the decline in perception of the sequel films, discussing both the positive and negative aspects.

The Good That Remained

Despite the shortcomings, there are moments of brilliance in the sequel trilogy. The cinematography, particularly in The Rise of Skywalker, stands out. The film also credits talented actors like Ian McDiarmid, Mark Hamill, and John Boyega for their exceptional performances. However, this praise is limited to the visual and acting aspects, as the sequels falter significantly in other areas.

The Flaws and Disappointments

The essential elements that made the original trilogy unique—diverse storytelling and depth of character—were largely absent in the sequel trilogy. The Force Awakens serves as the linchpin: a film that, while continuing the legacy, is also a cheap copy of A New Hope. Elements such as the duality of the forces and the characters' journeys are perpetuated without the originality needed to spark new excitement.

Character Development and Fan Expectations

The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi introduce characters like Kylo Ren and Rey, but their potential was wasted. Kylo Ren's motivation to follow in his grandfather's footsteps is poorly written, turning him into a cliché. Similarly, Rey, a Mary Sue character, suffers from a lack of development. These shortcomings failed to meet the high expectations set by the original trilogy's complex characters.

The Final Episode: A Criticized Capper

The Rise of Skywalker wraps up the story with mixed success, but issues remain. The film is criticized for its overreliance on tropes and unresolved plot points. The return of Palpatine without proper explanation and the creation of a massive Sith fleet on an inhospitable planet defy logic and continuity. Rey's acceptance of the identity 'Rey Skywalker' is perceived as a cheap and unrealistic plot device.

Subjectivity in Art and Individual Opinion

It's crucial to recognize that art is subjective. While the sequel trilogy may not resonate with many, it doesn't invalidate the positive opinions held by others. Fans and critics are entitled to their thoughts, regardless of whether their views align with the majority. Discussing these differences fosters a richer dialogue about the impact and evolution of a franchise.

Conclusion: The Star Wars sequel trilogy, while containing some redeeming visual and acting elements, ultimately fails to live up to the original trilogy's legacy due to its lack of original storytelling and character development. Whether you admire or disdain these films, it's important to cherish both the positives and the shortcomings, recognizing that art is a highly personal experience.